Table 4

Measurements for MCT and waiting list comparison group compared before treatment (T1, September 2009), after treatment or equivalent delay for waiting list patients (T2, March 2010) and differences
T1 (baseline) T2 (after treatment or waiting list) T2-T1 differences
No MCT MCT T/p No MCT MCT T/p No MCT MCT T/p
Mac-CAT-T
Understanding 4.2(1.3) 4.7(1.2) −0.9/>0.3 3.6(1.1) 5.1(0.9) −3.1/0.008 −0.5(0.5) +0.5(0.9) −3.0/0.009
Reasoning 5.0(1.9) 5.5(2.0) −0.5/>0.5 4.1(1.9) 6.2(1.1) −2.6/0.023 −0.9(2.2) +0.9(2.1) −1.7/>0.1
Appreciation 2.5(1.6) 2.7(1.5) −0.3/>0.7 2.4(1.5) 2.6(1.5) −0.4/>0.7 −0.13(0.9) −0.1(1.6) −0.01/>0.9
Total 11.8(4.3) 12.9(4.1) −0.6/>0.5 10.3(3.9) 13.9(2.5) −2.3/0.041 −1.5(2.9) +1.3(3.9) −1.7/>0.1
Mac-CAT-FP
Understanding 9.8(3.8) 9.8(3.5) −0.04/>0.9 10.6(3.7) 10.6(2.6) −0.7/>0.3 0.9(2.0) 2.2(1.7) −1.5/>0.1
Reasoning 7.1(1.9) 7.4(1.6) −0.3/>0.7 5.9(2.1) 7.8(2.2) −1.95/>0.05 −1.3(1.9) 0.5(1.6) −1.9/>0.05
Appreciation 8.3(3.5) 8.6(2.7) −0.03/>0.7 9.0(2.4) 9.4(2.7) −0.3/>0.7 0.8(2.7) 0.7(1.6) 0.02/>0.9
Total 23.9(7.5) 25.5(6.5) −0.5/>0.6 25.1(7.0) 29.2(7.1) −1.2/>0.2 1.3(5.9) 3.6(5.1) −0.9/>0.3
GAF 54.6(8.7) 50.6(9.5) 0.9/>0.3 48.0(6.9) 57.2(9.8) −2.6/0.021 −6.6(8.7) 6.6(12.0) −2.8/0.012
PANSS
PANSS positive 14.0(6.3) 11.4(3.7) 1.1/>0.2 15.3(5.4) 13.5(4.4) 0.8/>0.4 1.3(3.9) 2.2(4.9) 0.5/>0.6
PANSS negative 17.5(4.7) 17.7(6.7) 0.1/>0.9 20.5(4.2) 16.6(6.5) 0.6/>0.1 3.0(3.8) −1.1(6.5) 1.7/>0.1
PANSS general 27.0(6.6) 31.7(8.6) −1.4/>0.2 30.0(5.3) 29.4(10.2) 0.2/>0.8 3.0(4.9) −2.4(8.3) 1.8/>0.1
PANSS total 58.8(14.9) 60.7(15.2) −0.3/>0.7 66.0(8.3) 59.5(18.0) 1.0/>0.3 7.3(10.5) −1.2(18.6) 1.3/>0.2

Means (standard deviations), T statistic with equal variances not assumed, p values 2-tailed.

Naughton et al.

Naughton et al. BMC Research Notes 2012 5:302   doi:10.1186/1756-0500-5-302

Open Data