Table 8

Results, summary of the recommendations made the 17 evaluators for each of the 12 examples in the pilot study
Example
 Do it
 Probably do it
 Toss up
 Probably don't do it
 Don't do it
 Consensus
1
 4/16
 7/16
 3/16
 -
 2/16
 Probably do it
2
 6/16
 8/16
 2/16
 -
 -
 Do it
3
 -
 6/15
 7/15
 2/15
 -
 Need more information
4
 13/15
 2/15
 -
 -
 -
 Do it
5
 11/16
 5/16
 -
 -
 -
 Do it
6
 11/17
 5/17
 1/17
 -
 -
 Do it
7
 1/17
 7/17
 2/17
 6/17
 1/17
 Probably do it
8
 2/15
 7/15
 4/15
 2/15
 -
 Do it
9
 1/17
 4/17
 8/17
 4/17
 -
 Probably don't do it/Tossup
10
 -
 2/17
 6/17
 7/17
 2/17
 No consensus
11
 7/17
 8/17
 2/17
 -
 -
 Do it
12
 -
 -
 -
 4/13
 9/13
 No consensus

Atkins et al. BMC Health Services Research 2005 5:25   doi:10.1186/1472-6963-5-25