Debate

How old are you? Newborn gestational age discriminates neonatal resuscitation practices in the Italian debate

Emanuela Turillazzi and Vittorio Fineschi

Department of Legal Medicine. University of Foggia, Ospedale Colonnello D'Avanzo, Via degli Aviatori, 1, 71100 Foggia, Italy

author email corresponding author email

BMC Medical Ethics 2009, 10:19doi:10.1186/1472-6939-10-19

Published:	12 November 2009

Abstract

Background

Multidisciplinary study groups have produced documents in an attempt to support decisions regarding whether to resuscitate "at risk" newborns or not. Moreover, there has been an increasingly insistent request for juridical regulation of neonatal resuscitation practices as well as for clarification of the role of parents in decisions regarding this kind of assistance. The crux of the matter is whether strict guidelines, reference standards based on the parameter of gestational age and authority rules are necessary.

Discussion

The Italian scenario reflects the current animated debate, illustrating the difficulty intrinsic in rigid guidelines on the subject, especially when gestational age is taken as a reference parameter for the medical decision.

Summary

Concerning the decision to interrupt or not to initiate resuscitation procedures on low gestational age newborns, physicians do not need rigid rules based on inflexible gestational age and birth weight guidelines. Guidance in addressing the difficult and trying issues associated with infants born at the margins of viability with a realistic assessment of the infant's clinical condition must be based on the infant's best interests, with clinicians and parents entering into what has been described as a "partnership of care".