Email updates

Keep up to date with the latest news and content from BMC Public Health and BioMed Central.

This article is part of the supplement: The OptAIDS project: towards global halting of HIV/AIDS

Open Access Research

Halting HIV/AIDS with avatars and havatars: a virtual world approach to modelling epidemics

Richard Gordon1*, Natalie K Björklund2, Robert J Smith?3 and Eluemuno R Blyden4

Author Affiliations

1 Department of Radiology, University of Manitoba, GA216, HSC, 820 Sherbrook Street, Winnipeg, MB R3A 1R9, Canada

2 Silver Bog Research Inc., 350 Inkster Blvd., Winnipeg MB R2W 0K3, Canada

3 Department of Mathematics & Faculty of Medicine, The University of Ottawa, 585 King Edward Drive, Ottawa, ON K1N 6N5, Canada

4 AfriVax, Inc., 613 19th Ave. E. Suite 101, Seattle WA 98112, USA

For all author emails, please log on.

BMC Public Health 2009, 9(Suppl 1):S13  doi:10.1186/1471-2458-9-S1-S13


The electronic version of this article is the complete one and can be found online at: http://www.biomedcentral.com/1471-2458/9/S1/S13


Published:18 November 2009

© 2009 Gordon et al; licensee BioMed Central Ltd.

This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.

Abstract

Background

A major deficit of all approaches to epidemic modelling to date has been the need to approximate or guess at human behaviour in disease-transmission-related contexts. Avatars are generally human-like figures in virtual computer worlds controlled by human individuals.

Methods

We introduce the concept of a "havatar", which is a (human, avatar) pairing. Evidence is mounting that this pairing behaves in virtual contexts much like the human in the pairing might behave in analogous real-world contexts.

Results

We propose that studies of havatars, in a virtual world, may give a realistic approximation of human behaviour in real-world contexts. If the virtual world approximates the real world in relevant details (geography, transportation, etc.), virtual epidemics in that world could accurately simulate real-world epidemics. Havatar modelling of epidemics therefore offers a complementary tool for tackling how best to halt epidemics, including perhaps HIV/AIDS, since sexual behaviour is a significant component of some virtual worlds, such as Second Life.

Conclusion

Havatars place the control parameters of an epidemic in the hands of each individual. By providing tools that everyone can understand and use, we could democratise epidemiology.

Background

Epidemiology has always had control of epidemics as its goal. Ever since we discovered that mosquitoes transmit malaria, we have sought points of control, from eradication of mosquito larvae, to screening of windows and beds, to the development of vaccines, to more abstract points of control, such as keeping the reproductive rate of an epidemic, R0, below 1 [1]. With HIV/AIDS, like the cartoon character Pogo, "We have met the enemy and he is us" [2]. While for decades we have hoped that an effective vaccine is just around the corner [3], "HIV-vaccine research [is] a field that has endured a Sisyphean onslaught of disappointments" [4], so that, for now, it is our own behaviour that brings or avoids HIV/AIDS. We have to look within, rather than to externalities, for control points. Virtual worlds potentially offer unprecedented levels of access to the internal dynamics of behaviour, complete with a new set of ethical issues.

Epidemiology modelling has generally followed two major approaches: the continuous and the discrete. In the continuous (deterministic) approach, we use differential or partial differential equations, characterised by lumped or aggregated variables and presumed constants relating them. We try to predict the variables, such as the number of susceptible or infected people, given constants, such as the rate of transmission [5,6]. In the discrete (individual) approach [7], we divide the population into individuals, and try to model their interactions, sometimes describing them as occurring on a social network, which is a discrete structure in the sense of graph theory. This discrete structure can take the extreme of complete representation of urban geography and transportation [8]. An analogy may be made with the physics of fluids. We may try to solve the continuous equations of fluid flow, as in computational fluid dynamics [9], or we may try to simulate the behaviour of all the individual molecules in the fluid and their interactions with those they come in contact with, as in Monte Carlo molecular dynamics [10-14].

Stochastic process modelling [15] represents a compromise, in which we attempt to use aggregated parameters when approximating large populations, but add in "noise" to represent individual variations. Stochastic models generally agree with deterministic models when the disease is endemic, but may differ significantly when the disease is close to extinction or just starting. Stochastic effects tend to drive outcomes that are near zero to actual extinction, which would theoretically take an infinite amount of time in deterministic models.

Certain control points, i.e., parameters that we think we can manipulate to alter the course of an epidemic, are evident with HIV/AIDS. For example, it has long been known that HIV/AIDS could be significantly controlled with condoms, if only we could get enough people to use them [16-21]. Thailand took this approach, which met with great success [22,23], but continual attention is needed as behaviour changes [24]. For example, the growth of intravenous drug use provides a route of transmission for which condoms are ineffective, exasperated by the observation that condom use is difficult to promote amongst intravenous drug users for protecting their sexual partners [25]. For HIV/AIDS, we must therefore have multiple control points.

Two observations, however, make the multiple control point approach dubious [26]. First is the observation of, at best, a weak correlation between the aggregated parameters of the continuous approach, that cannot be dismissed as mere statistical inaccuracy in estimating parameters [27]. In other words, when we guess at what factors are important (such as aggregating people into certain categories) and how they should affect one another (such as presuming which aggregated groups mate with which other groups), the predictive value of our models proves to be quite poor, or downright wrong. More refined continuous models help to some extent in unravelling deeper causal relations and improving correlations, but the very concept that all people in one group randomly mate with people in another group is obviously a poor approximation to how, where, when and how often they actually pair up. Poisson statistics are implicitly assumed, which are themselves but a crude approximation to the time course of human behaviour.

The second doubt [26] about the multiple-control-point approach is the dynamic nature of networks of human sexual behaviour when controls are applied. For example, police action may close down one venue for sex work, but an alternative arises to replace it. Thus, shifting behaviour and "hidden groups" [28,29] not foreseen by field workers make control points a matter of guesswork. One hope is that a higher understanding of dynamic networks as complex systems may give us new points of control [26], but how to observe changing networks of behaviour with limited field work resources is problematic.

In a way, these efforts to refine different models make them approach one another. We discretise the continuous approach, by subdividing aggregated parameters, or smooth the discrete approach, by looking at the overall behaviour of networks, their so-called emergent features. But do they thereby better approximate the real world?

While we try to empower people through education, stigma reduction, harm reduction, free condoms, needle exchange programs, etc., the role of the individual in halting the HIV/AIDS epidemic is basically passive with these approaches. We somehow hope that when they choose a mate, engage a sex worker, etc., individuals will modify their behaviour in a way that reduces or eliminates their contribution to the dynamics of the epidemic. When they fail to do as we hope, we attribute this to inadequate education or empowerment, or the heat of the moment. We expect that, somehow, our grand view of the epidemic, as professional epidemiologists or modellers, will influence individuals' behaviours and thus affect parameters such as the rate of transmission. Analogous to the continuum between the discrete and the continuous in our models, however, the socio-cultural "view" of the epidemic ranges from the local one of the individual in the epidemic, to that of the global view of scientists, mathematicians, health economists and epidemiologists who actually deal with a lumped or aggregated conceptualization of the epidemic. Even when they are successfully communicated, faith in different views of the epidemic is rarely shared between all concerned. People have different priorities and relate differently to the need for behavioural change - ultimately underpinned by differences in valuations of life and death itself. The consequences are not trivial. The success of science in understanding HIV/AIDS has relied heavily on the willing co-operation of individuals whose view of the epidemic cannot prevent them from interacting with it, such as sex workers and intravenous drug users.

A new approach to epidemic modelling using havatars

All epidemic modelling to date approximates and second-guesses human behaviour. We would like to propose an alternative way to model HIV/AIDS, that lets each individual person decide on the control parameters for their life, and which makes their actual behaviour part of the modelling. Our suggestion is an old approach, what used to be called "enlightened self-interest" [30]. It assumes, contrary to the "tragedy of the commons" [31], that what is best for the individual from their own point of view will be best for society as a whole. That is, of course, unproven for HIV/AIDS, so what we are proposing here is a new avenue of epidemiological research.

We start with the observation that, in certain virtual worlds, which appear to be those where the participants construct the rules of engagement with one another themselves, there seems to be a correlation between the personality of a person's avatar [32] and their own self [33-35]. For compactness of language, we will define a person:avatar pair as a "havatar", where the "h" stands for "human"; thus, havatar = (human, avatar). The nature of these pairings (i.e., the identity formed) depends on the way the virtual world is set up. Second Life generally has havatars [33], whereas games in which a person has multiple avatars under their control may diminish the correlation or create more complex correlations. The self-constructed or self-selected nature of the rules, landscape, furniture, vehicles, clothing and architecture in Second Life may also invite imitation of each person's real life, making it much more "true to life".

In adult virtual worlds, as in the internet itself, a significant fraction of the interactions between havatars is sexual [36]. HIV/AIDS cannot, of course, be transmitted between avatars, so that sex in a virtual world could be the ultimate in safe sex. Nevertheless, computer viruses have actually been transmitted between avatars, both accidentally and intentionally [37]. One remarkable observation about these social experiments is that havatars undertake behaviours of evasion of the avatar epidemic that are similar to those humans might take in an analogous real life situation. In other words, the equation of the avatar with "one's self" may be quite strong in havatars. One could add visible symptoms, pre- and post-phylactic interventions, simulated funerals, etc., to make quite a visual impact and provide different "views" of the epidemic. Mythologies developed about how to avoid an avatar epidemic [37], which remind one of mythologies about HIV/AIDS, from total denialism [38] to counterproductive practices that infect others [39-41].

Beyond this, each individual has the opportunity of seeing the epidemic at any scale, through statistics gathered by the computer program running the virtual world, creation of maps, communication with and knowledge about other havatars, and by being allowed to run computer simulations of the epidemic themselves. For example, in Second Life, one can examine the profile of any havatar, which includes the names of the groups they belong to, and decide whether or not to become "friends" with them. Such textual, quantitative and visual tools can provide people with objective criteria that relate their own behaviour to an epidemic, and give them opportunities to change that behaviour to avoid being part of it.

Havatars thus present the possibility of a bottom-up approach to epidemic control. They are already being used to plan for emergencies caused by epidemics [42,43], so why not to study actual epidemics? If people identify with their avatars, we could imagine the possibility of everyone taking control of HIV/AIDS in their own lives, based on information about the epidemic attained through a virtual world. This assumes, of course, a strong correlation between real life, person-to-person sex, and the corresponding havatar-to-havatar sex. The latter allows more "positions" than most people are capable of actually doing, and one could assume that people might take more risks as havatars than they would in real life. We know from real life that such additional risk-taking extends the range of experimental opportunity for scientific studies of HIV/AIDS. If epidemiologist havatars could experiment with scenarios themselves, new discoveries about the subtleties of human-virus interaction might be uncovered. Clearly, we need some research on whether the correlations between real and havatar personalities [33] extend to sexual behaviour.

Discussion

Havatars could be used by epidemiological modellers in a variety of ways. The simplest would be to unleash simulated viruses that can infect avatars, are invisible, have no effects, but whose transmission from one havatar to another can be monitored. This has a large advantage over real-life networks in that the latter require tremendous amounts of fieldwork to uncover. Furthermore, such fieldwork might itself alter the social network. Details of where, when, what acts, and with whom have the general unreliability of self-reporting; fieldwork at best gives a snapshot of a dynamic system, while in a virtual world all this data could be made available on a continuous basis. Waivers that allow tracking of all transactions were signed by all 13 million Second Life participants [44] when they joined [45]. The social networks of havatars observed in a virtual world may prove a better representation of real-world disease transmission networks than any attempt at direct observation of the real world could ever produce.

The research on havatars that we propose raises questions of privacy, ethics and informed consent that are unresolved as of now, but it has been suggested that the general difficulty of a person knowing which other real life person corresponds to a given havatar may keep these problems at bay [46].

The next level of havatar epidemiology research would be to create consequences of disease transmission. In virtual worlds, people react to parameters at many levels, and have the opportunity to grasp a situation as a whole [47]. This is what makes multilevel control by havatars a potentially powerful means of epidemic control, because the person involved has the opportunity to grasp the epidemic in many ways. We can see this operating in the simulated "Whypox" epidemics [37]. Two simple consequences occurred for avatars: they acquired spots on their skins that the person could not remove, and they "sneezed", interjecting the word "achoo" at random in typed conversations between havatars, sometimes requiring retyping of a command that would have initiated an animated sequence. The people behind the avatars reacted strongly to this imposed situation, and changed their behaviour to alleviate or avoid it.

For an HIV/AIDS simulation, we could envision more drastic consequences for havatars, with permission of their human components. For example, most people design their avatars to look good. Simulated HIV/AIDS might make them look ghastly, with weight loss, etc., cause them to interrupt their behaviour to take antiretroviral drugs, or even get too sick to do much and die. This might lead to stigma, formation of ALWA groups (Avatars Living With AIDS), etc. Analogous avatar effects have been simulated for neurological conditions [48]. Economic losses [49,50], such as (simulated) drug costs, could also be of consequence not only to the avatar and its accoutrements, but also to the real-life person who has to pay for some of them with real money [51]. Thus, with such an epidemiological experiment, we would start crossing the virtual/real-world boundary. This boundary crossing can clearly be seen in the behaviour of real life married couples who enter a virtual world [52].

The third level of epidemiological research would fully cross the virtual world/real-world boundary. This is already being done with computer-controlled sex toys that can be controlled by other havatars [53], and could be regarded as an extension of the search for self-knowledge, which often involves sexual behaviour [54]. Of course, so long as these toys aren't shared between real people, real HIV won't be transmitted. But if the avatars can be computer infected, their people might react accordingly. This raises the general question of whether internet sex, like phone sex, will become sufficiently widespread, perhaps because of these remotely controllable haptic devices, to impact and cut into real-world sex work (Joel Kettner, personal communication). The argument that condom availability promotes promiscuous behaviour rapidly lost out to the perception that condoms prevent disease transmission, and, at least in the case of Thailand, promotion of condom use and HIV/AIDS awareness led to a decline in sex work [24]. Similarly, the current notion that the Internet facilitates sexual contacts may lose out to idea that the Internet prevents real disease transmission.

Whether havatar sex will have an impact on HIV transmission between real humans is of course not yet known. When one havatar encounters another, they can examine each other's "profiles", which include, for example, listings of the groups they belong to. The record could show simulated HIV status as one of the consequences in the virtual world. Attempts to do anything similar in the real world are limited so far. Sex clubs and pornography actors have tried to restrict membership to HIV-free people, and a few cases of failure to divulge one's HIV status have hit the courts, but how this plays out in daily life is uncertain, and obviously of insufficient impact to halt the HIV/AIDS epidemic. Transferring codes of ethics developed in virtual worlds to real life is problematic, though even in the freewheeling atmosphere of Second Life, the reverse has already occurred in terms of gambling and banking [55]. However, havatars give us an interesting tool with which to explore these options for epidemic control.

It will be argued against this approach that the cost of Internet access is beyond the poor populations of the world where HIV/AIDS flourishes most, and that the havatar population is thus a biased sampling of the human population. However, if we consider the rate of adoption of cell phones [56] or programs to introduce rugged, hand- and solar-powered, internet-connectable computers at low cost worldwide [57], the democratising influence of virtual worlds [58], and the widespread use of the internet to make sexual contacts [59], this leapfrogging might occur quite rapidly.

Conclusion

This paper is part of an effort to develop a worldwide model of the HIV/AIDS epidemic and how to control and stop it, beginning with the MITACS http://www.mitacs.math.ca/ webcite OptAIDS Workshop July 29, 2008 in Toronto. The goal, WHAM, the World Halting AIDS Model, [60,61] might be just a grand epidemiology simulation in the deterministic and/or stochastic moulds. However, if we let the people of the world simulate themselves through havatars, we may collectively see our way past this unfortunate pandemic, and who knows what else that may lie ahead. We may need a new approach, since, for all the work that has been done on trying to control the HIV/AIDS epidemic, it is our impression that, for the most part, we have just helplessly watched it grow.

The aim of epidemiological modelling has always been to gain control of epidemics. HIV/AIDS is an epidemic that is very much depends on the decisions made by individuals. Controlling them, telling people what to do for their own or the greater, common good, has proven to be a difficult and sometimes thankless task. Perhaps what we need to do is examine the relationship between the modeller and those modelled. Havatars give us an opportunity to reverse that relationship and place the control parameters in the hands of each individual. The modeller can enable this democratisation of epidemiology by providing tools for global and other perspectives that everyone can understand and use.

Competing interests

The authors declare that they have no competing interests.

Authors' contributions

RG wrote the first draft. All authors read and approved the final manuscript.

Acknowledgements

Supported in part by a grant from MITACS as part of the OptAIDS Workshop. RJS is also supported by an NSERC Discovery grant and an Early Researcher award. Handling editor for this manuscript was Jane Heffernan.

This article has been published as part of BMC Public Health Volume 9 Supplement 1, 2009: The OptAIDS project: towards global halting of HIV/AIDS. The full contents of the supplement are available online at http://www.biomedcentral.com/1471-2458/9?issue=S1.

References

  1. Heffernan JM, Smith RJ, Wahl LM: Perspectives on the basic reproductive ratio.

    J R Soc Interface 2005, 2(4):281-293. PubMed Abstract | Publisher Full Text | PubMed Central Full Text OpenURL

  2. White M: [http://www.igopogo.com/we_have_met.htm] webcite

    "We have met the enemy... and he is us". 2008. OpenURL

  3. Lau CY, Velasco PP, Johnston MI: A new era in HIV vaccine development.

    Expert Rev Anti Infect Ther 2007, 5(2):205-215. PubMed Abstract | Publisher Full Text OpenURL

  4. Markel H: The search for effective HIV vaccines.

    N Engl J Med 2005, 353(8):753-757. PubMed Abstract | Publisher Full Text OpenURL

  5. Brauer F, Castillo-Chavez C: Mathematical Models in Population Biology and Epidemiology. New York: Springer; 2001. OpenURL

  6. Hethcote HW: The mathematics of infectious diseases.

    SIAM Review 2000, 42(4):599-653. Publisher Full Text OpenURL

  7. Keeling MJ, Eames KT: Networks and epidemic models.

    J R Soc Interface 2005, 2(4):295-307. PubMed Abstract | Publisher Full Text | PubMed Central Full Text OpenURL

  8. Borkowski M, Podaima BW, McLeod MD: Epidemic Modeling with Discrete-Space Scheduled Walkers: Extensions and Research Opportunities.

    BMC Public Health 2009, 9(Suppl 1):S14. PubMed Abstract | PubMed Central Full Text OpenURL

  9. Nouri C, Luppes R, Veldman AEP, Tuszynski JA, Gordon R: Rayleigh instability of the inverted one-cell amphibian embryo [Invited: "Physical Aspects of Developmental Biology" special issue, Guest Editor Shane Hutson, Vanderbilt University].

    Physical Biology 2008, 5(1):15006. PubMed Abstract | Publisher Full Text OpenURL

  10. Gordon R: Monte Carlo methods for cooperative Ising models. In Cooperative Phenomena in Biology. Edited by Karreman G. New York: Pergamon Press; 1980.

    189-241 + errata.

    OpenURL

  11. Burghaus U: A practical guide to kinetic Monte Carlo simulations and classical molecular dynamics simulations: an example book. New York: Nova Science Publishers; 2006. OpenURL

  12. Griebel M, Knapek S, Zumbusch GW: Numerical simulation in molecular dynamics: numerics, algorithms, parallelization, applications. Berlin: Springer; 2007. OpenURL

  13. Rapaport DC: The art of molecular dynamics simulation. 2nd edition. Cambridge, UK; New York, NY: Cambridge University Press; 2004. OpenURL

  14. Serdyuk IN, Zaccai NR, Zaccai G: Methods in molecular biophysics: structure, dynamics, function. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press; 2007. OpenURL

  15. Mode CJ, Sleeman CK: Stochastic Processes in Epidemiology: HIV/AIDS, Other Infectious Diseases. Singapore: World Scientific; 2000. OpenURL

  16. Bracher M, Santow G, Watkins SC: Assessing the potential of condom use to prevent the spread of HIV: a microsimulation study.

    Stud Fam Plann 2004, 35(1):48-64. PubMed Abstract | Publisher Full Text OpenURL

  17. Dalal N, Greenhalgh D, Mao X: A stochastic model of AIDS and condom use.

    J Math Anal Appl 2007, 325:36-53. Publisher Full Text OpenURL

  18. Foss AM, Watts CH, Vickerman P, Heise L: Condoms and prevention of HIV.

    BMJ 2004, 329(7459):185-186. PubMed Abstract | Publisher Full Text | PubMed Central Full Text OpenURL

  19. Gordon R: A critical review of the physics and statistics of condoms and their role in individual versus societal survival of the AIDS epidemic.

    J Sex Marital Ther 1989, 15(1):5-30. PubMed Abstract OpenURL

  20. Holmes KK, Levine R, Weaver M: Effectiveness of condoms in preventing sexually transmitted infections.

    Bull World Health Organ 2004, 82(6):454-461. PubMed Abstract | PubMed Central Full Text OpenURL

  21. Moghadas SM, Gumel AB, McLeod RG, Gordon R: Could condoms stop the AIDS epidemic?

    Journal of Theoretical Medicine 2004, 5(3-4):171-181. Publisher Full Text OpenURL

  22. Hearst N, Chen S: Condom promotion for AIDS prevention in the developing world: is it working?

    Stud Fam Plann 2004, 35(1):39-47. PubMed Abstract | Publisher Full Text OpenURL

  23. Rojanapithayakorn W: The 100% condom use programme in Asia.

    Reprod Health Matters 2006, 14(28):41-52. PubMed Abstract | Publisher Full Text OpenURL

  24. Hanenberg R, Rojanapithayakorn W: Changes in prostitution and the AIDS epidemic in Thailand.

    AIDS Care 1998, 10(1):69-79. PubMed Abstract OpenURL

  25. Vanichseni S, Des Jarlais DC, Choopanya K, Mock PA, Kitayaporn D, Sangkhum U, Prasithiphol B, Hu DJ, van Griensven F, Mastro TD, et al.: Sexual risk reduction in a cohort of injecting drug users in Bangkok, Thailand.

    J Acquir Immune Defic Syndr 2004, 37(1):1170-1179. PubMed Abstract | Publisher Full Text OpenURL

  26. Blanchard J: Looking beyond the trees and the forest: the public health relevance of the social ecology and emergent properties of sex work organization. Winnipeg: Department of Community Health Sciences, University of Manitoba; 2008. OpenURL

  27. Kault DA: The impact of sexual mixing patterns on the spread of AIDS.

    Math Biosci 1995, 128(1-2):211-241. PubMed Abstract | Publisher Full Text OpenURL

  28. Nguyen TA, Oosterhoff P, Hardon A, Tran HN, Coutinho RA, Wright P: A hidden HIV epidemic among women in Vietnam.

    BMC Public Health 2008, 8:37. PubMed Abstract | BioMed Central Full Text | PubMed Central Full Text OpenURL

  29. Magnani R, Sabin K, Saidel T, Heckathorn D: Review of sampling hard-to-reach and hidden populations for HIV surveillance.

    AIDS 2005, 19(Suppl 2):S67-72. PubMed Abstract | Publisher Full Text OpenURL

  30. de Tocqueville ACHMC: Democracy in America. London: Saunders & Otley; 1838. OpenURL

  31. Hardin G: The tragedy of the commons.

    Science 1968, 162:1243-1248. Publisher Full Text OpenURL

  32. Damer B: Avatars: Exploring and Building Virtual Worlds on the Internet. Berkeley: Peachpit Press; 1997. OpenURL

  33. Yee N, Bailenson JN, Urbanek M, Chang F, Merget D: The unbearable likeness of being digital: The persistence of nonverbal social norms in online virtual environments.

    Cyberpsychology & Behaviour 2007, 10(1):115-121. Publisher Full Text OpenURL

  34. Kushner D: Virtual connections - My avatar, my self.

    Technology Review 2004, 107(3):50-55. OpenURL

  35. Yee N, Bailenson J: The Proteus Effect: The effect of transformed self-representation on behaviour.

    Human Communication Research 2007, 33(3):271-290. Publisher Full Text OpenURL

  36. Offman C: Virtual Babylon: Second Life offers social networking with a happy ending--and only vanilla sex is taboo. [http://www.nationalpost.com/loveandsex/story.html?id=296040] webcite

    National Post 2008. OpenURL

  37. Kafai YB, Feldon D, Fields D, Giang M, Quintero M: Life in the times of Whypox: a virtual epidemic as a community event. In Communities and Technologies 2007: Proceedings of the Third Communities and Technologies Conference, Michigan State University. Edited by Steinfeld C, Pentland B, Ackermann M, Contractor N. London: Springer; 2007:171-190. OpenURL

  38. Bateman C: Paying the price for AIDS denialism.

    S Afr Med J 2007, 97(10):912-914. PubMed Abstract | Publisher Full Text OpenURL

  39. Bowley DM, Pitcher GJ: Motivation behind infant rape in South Africa.

    Lancet 2002, 359(9314):1352. PubMed Abstract | Publisher Full Text OpenURL

  40. Davidson R: This pernicious delusion: law, medicine and child sexual abuse in early 20th Century Scotland.

    J Hist Sex 2001, 10:62-67. PubMed Abstract | Publisher Full Text OpenURL

  41. Jewkes R, Martin L, Penn-Kekana L: The virgin cleansing myth: cases of child rape are not exotic.

    Lancet 2002, 359(9307):711. PubMed Abstract | Publisher Full Text OpenURL

  42. Mitchell RL: Surviving bird flu with Second Life. [http:/ / www.computerworlduk.com/ management/ security/ disaster-recovery/ in-depth/ index.cfm?articleid=341] webcite

    2007.

  43. Ullberg L, Monahan C, Harvey K: The New Face of emergency preparedness training: using Second Life to save first lives.

    In Second Life Education Workshop 2007, Part of the Second Life Community Convention, Chicago Hilton, 24th-26th August 2007 Edited by Livingstone D, Kemp J. 2007, 96-99. OpenURL

  44. Linden Labs: [http://secondlife.com/whatis/economy_stats.php] webcite

    Second Life Economic Statistics. Last Updated: Monday, March 31, 2008. 2008. OpenURL

  45. Linden Lab Legal Department: [http://secondlife.com/corporate/tos.php] webcite

    Terms of Service. 2008. OpenURL

  46. Bainbridge WS: The scientific research potential of virtual worlds.

    Science 2007, 317(5837):472-476. PubMed Abstract | Publisher Full Text OpenURL

  47. Leigh J, Brown MD: Cyber-commons: Merging real and virtual worlds.

    Communications of the ACM 2008, 51:82-85. Publisher Full Text OpenURL

  48. Boulos MNK, Hetherington L, Wheeler S: Second Life: an overview of the potential of 3-D virtual worlds in medical and health education.

    Health Information and Libraries Journal 2007, 24:233-245. PubMed Abstract | Publisher Full Text OpenURL

  49. Naone E: Financial woes in second life.

    Technology Review 2007, 110:13. OpenURL

  50. Bloomfield R: The microeconomics of fantasyland. Second Life represents the first 'entrepreneurial virtual world.' It is also testing the real-world boundaries of everything from tax law to banking regulation.

    National Post 2008. OpenURL

  51. Ondrejka C: [http://ssrn.com/abstract=614663] webcite

    Aviators, moguls, fashionistas and barons: economics and ownership in Second Life. 2004. OpenURL

  52. Linden H: [http://secondlife.blogs.com/nwn/2005/05/your_cheating_h.html] webcite

    Your Cheating Heart: A survey on the morality of in-world romance provokes several Second Life lessons-- learned, and unlearned. 2005. OpenURL

  53. Lynn R: [http://www.wired.com/gaming/virtualworlds/commentary/sexdrive/2006/08/71657] webcite

    Second Life Gets Sexier. 2006. OpenURL

  54. Blyden ER, Gordon R: Genomics, pharmacology and 3D imaging: self-knowledge in the post-genomic era.

    Biotechnology Focus 2000, 3(6):14-16. OpenURL

  55. Linden KD: [http://blog.secondlife.com/2008/01/08/new-policy-regarding-in-world-banks/] webcite

    New Policy Regarding In-World "Banks". 2008. OpenURL

  56. Brummitt C: [http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/20479899/] webcite

    Cell-phone use booming in Afghanistan: Service providers bring communication to poor villagers. [Associated Press]; 2007. OpenURL

  57. Negroponte N: [http://www.laptop.org/] webcite

    One Laptop per Child. 2008. OpenURL

  58. Søraker JH: Global freedom of expression within nontextual frameworks.

    Information Society 2008, 24:40-46. Publisher Full Text OpenURL

  59. Ross MW, Rosser BR, McCurdy S, Feldman J: The advantages and limitations of seeking sex online: a comparison of reasons given for online and offline sexual liaisons by men who have sex with men.

    J Sex Res 2007, 44(1):59-71. PubMed Abstract | Publisher Full Text OpenURL

  60. Smith? RJ, Gordon R: The OptAIDS project: towards global halting of HIV/AIDS.

    BMC Public Health 2009, 9(Suppl 1):S1. OpenURL

  61. Smith? RJ, Li J, Gordon R, Heffernan J: Can we spend our way out of the AIDS epidemic? A world halting AIDS model.

    BMC Public Health 2009, 9(Suppl 1):S15. PubMed Abstract | PubMed Central Full Text OpenURL