Age and gender differences of psychogenic fever: a review of the Japanese literature

1751-0759-1-11 1751-0759 Review Age and gender differences of psychogenic fever: a review of the Japanese literature Oka Takakazu toka@med.uoeh-u.ac.jp Oka Kae okakae@hotmail.com

Psychosomatic Medicine Division, Department of Neurology, University of Occupational and Environmental Health, Japan Iseigaoka 1-1, Yahatanishi-ku, Kitakyushu, 807-8555, Japan

Pediatrics Department, Faculty of Medicine, Kurume University Asahimachi 67, Kurume, 830-0011, Japan

BioPsychoSocial Medicine 1751-0759 2007 1 1 11 http://www.bpsmedicine.com/content/1/1/11 17511878 10.1186/1751-0759-1-11 01 2 2007 19 5 2007 19 5 2007 2007 Oka and Oka; licensee BioMed Central Ltd. This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.

Abstract

Background

Psychogenic fever is one of the most common psychosomatic diseases. Patients with psychogenic fever have acute or persistent body temperature above normal range in psychologically stressful situations. In spite of numerous case reports on psychogenic fever, there are few epidemiological studies. Therefore, our goal was to investigate the age distribution and gender differences of psychogenic fever in Japan.

Methods

To achieve this goal, we searched Medline and Ichushi WEB, a Japanese medical database, and added other publications that were not included in these databases. Thus, we reviewed 195 Japanese cases of psychogenic fever published in 62 papers.

Results

Psychogenic fever patients ranged from 3 to 56 years old, with the highest number of cases occurring in 13 year-olds in both sexes. The male: female ratio of 1: 1.19 suggested a slight predominance of female cases. Psychogenic fever accounted for 18% of fever cases of unknown origin in children and 2–6% of the psychosomatic diseases of pediatric patients. Patients with psychogenic fever were not only found in pediatrics departments, but also in psychosomatic medicine, psychiatry, internal medicine, anesthesiology, dentistry, and obstetrics/gynecology departments.

Conclusion

The age of psychogenic fever patients ranged from 3 to 56 years old and the male: female ratio was 1:1.19. Psychogenic fever is seen especially in adolescence in Japan.

Background

Psychogenic fever is one of the most common psychosomatic diseases; physical diseases affected by psychosocial factors. Psychogenic fever is diagnosed when (1) there is no organic disease that accounts for the fever and (2) the fever develops in a psychologically stressful situation or (3) emotionally stressful stimuli induce acute or persistent increases in core temperature (Tc) above the upper limit of normal body temperature (37°C). Although numerous case reports on psychogenic fever have been published, the mechanisms by which psychological stress increases core temperature are not fully understood, and epidemiological studies are limited. Therefore, our primary objective was to investigate the age distribution and gender differences of psychogenic fever in Japan by reviewing the published literature.

Methods

To achieve this goal, on January 15^th, 2007 using the key words "psychogenic fever" we performed electronic searches of Medline (1960–2006) and Ichushi WEB (1983 (the beginning of the service)-2006), a database of the NPO Japan Medical Abstract Society. The search identified 61 publications that included original papers, case reports, review articles, abstracts, or proceedings. Because the aim of this study was to determine the age distribution and gender differences of Japanese patients with psychogenic fever, we included abstracts and proceedings if the age and gender of the patients were described. However, the following were excluded from this study: (1) abstracts and proceedings that were subsequently published as original articles or case reports; (2) papers that did not distinguish psychogenic fever from factitious fever; (3) review articles that did not refer to cases; (4) papers that exclusively described animal studies; and (5) papers in which the involvement of psychosocial factors on the development of fever was unclear. Thus, 23 papers were excluded. We additionally included 24 papers that the reviewed papers had cited or that we personally identified but that were not included in Medline or Ichushi WEB. Thus, in total we reviewed 62 papers 1234567891011121314151617181920212223242526272829303132333435363738394041424344454647484950515253545556575859606162.

Statistic analysis

Data are shown as the mean ± standard deviation (SD). Student's t-test for unmatched data and Kolmogorov-Smirnov test were applied to analyze statistical differences between groups.

Results

The papers that we reviewed were segregated into two types. ''Type 1'' includes those in which we could identify the age and sex of each patient. ''Type 2'' includes papers in which age and gender were described in groups, such as five patients (three male and two female) between 8–10 years old. Of the 195 cases identified, 135 were type 1 and 60 were type 2. If the paper described the patients as being in the 1^st, 2^nd, or 3^rdgrade of junior high school, we assumed their ages to be 13, 14, and 15 years old, respectively.

1) Gender differences

Of the 195 cases, 89 (45.6%) were male and 106 (54.4%) were female. The male: female ratio of 1: 1.19 demonstrated a slight predominance of females over males.

2) Age distribution

In the type 1 papers, psychogenic fever patients ranged from 3 to 56 years old. The youngest case was a three-year-old girl who developed a 38°C fever each time she sat in a dentist's chair but had the fever return to within the normal range when she went home 39. The oldest case was a fifty-six-year-old man with depression who had a persistent low-grade (37–38°C) fever in psychologically stressful situations 22. The mean age at onset was 13.7 ± 8.6 years for males, 14.9 ± 9.3 years for females: 14.3 ± 9.0 for all cases. Age was not statistically different between males and females. The mode was 13 years for both sexes (Fig. 1). Patients between 11 and 15 years old were the most numerous: 52.6% of all cases (71). Patients between 6 and 10 years old were the second largest group: 40 cases (29.6%).

Figure 1

Age distribution of psychogenic fever patients by sex: Male (A), female (B) and both sexes (C)

Age distribution of psychogenic fever patients by sex: Male (A), female (B) and both sexes (C).

Among the type 2 papers, three reported on 10 or more cases 101416. All three papers were published by pediatricians and concluded that psychogenic fever is most frequently seen in 12–13 year-olds 10, 50% of psychogenic fever patients are 13 years old 14 and 72% of psychogenic fever patients are 12–14 years old 16. These results were comparable to those of the type 1 papers.

3) The rate of psychogenic fever by department

Most reports on psychogenic fever were published by pediatricians (22 papers, 35.5%). Others were contributed by physicians specializing in psychosomatic medicine (19 papers), psychiatry (11 papers), internal medicine (2 papers), anesthesiology (2 papers), obstetrics/gynecology (1 paper), dentistry (1 paper), psychotherapy (3 papers) and education (1 paper). Examples of psychogenic fever in three departments are as follows.

Pediatrics

Hashira et al. 24 reviewed fever of unknown origin (FUO) in children and reported that 23 (18.3%) out of 126 patients with FUO were finally diagnosed as psychogenic fever. The rate of psychogenic fever was 1.9–5.8% of all patients with functional psychosomatic diseases who visited the department of pediatrics outpatient clinic at Nagoya City Hospital in 1970, 1975, 1980, and 1985 28.

Psychiatry

Among outpatients who visited the department of child psychiatry at Hamamatsu Medical School between 1982 and 1985, the percentage of psychogenic fever patients was 5.2% 20.

Obstetrics/gynecology

Among climacteric outpatients who visited an obstetrics/gynecology clinic complaining of low-grade fever, 8 out of 182 patients (4.4%) were diagnosed with psychogenic fever 54.

Discussion

This study reviewed 195 cases of psychogenic fever, the largest number of cases that has ever been investigated and compiled in Japan. The results showed that the age of patients ranged from 3 to 56 years old, peaking at 13 years old, and that the male: female ratio of 1:1.19 showed a slight predominance of female cases over male cases. Most psychogenic fever patients visit pediatricians; however, such patients were seen in a wide variety of departments including psychosomatic medicine, psychiatry, and gynecology.

Ages

Psychogenic fever patients were predominantly seen between 8–15 years-of-age, and especially at 13 years of age, in both sexes. This age range corresponds to the onset and duration of adolescence. Therefore, although the reasons for such an age distribution are unclear, autonomic and hormonal changes or psychological instability in adolescence may contribute to the high rates seen at these ages. Another possibility is that pediatricians are more aware of stress-induced hyperthermic responses because children have a higher body temperature than adults. For example, patients between 10–15 years sometimes exhibited temperatures of 39–41°C 34711323335384348. In contrast, most adult patients showed only 37–38°C 5223446495355606162. Therefore, in the case of adult patients, physicians might pay little attention to hyperthermic responses, including those that are produced by psychological stress. Interestingly, there were only four cases reported in the 40–59 years-old range. However, considering that 4% of the low-grade fever of climacteric patients is psychogenic fever, there should be more patients in this age range. Some adult patients might be diagnosed with chronic fatigue syndrome (CFS) because CFS patients also have low-grade fever of unknown origin and physical symptoms exacerbated by stress. However, psychogenic fever is different from CFS 59 for the following reasons. The onset of psychogenic fever is not sudden. Psychogenic fever patients complain little of muscle weakness, myalgia, arthralgia, or chill. Cervical lymphadenopathy or infected pharynx is not observed. Furthermore, psychogenic fever is curable by stress reduction and conflict resolution via psychotropic drugs and psychotherapy.

Gender differences

Several reports discussed gender differences in psychogenic fever. However, the results were conflicting: a predominance of males 16, females 20, or no difference 14. The reasons for contradictory results may partly be due to the relatively small numbers of cases investigated (10–27 cases). The present study reviewed the largest number of cases ever published and revealed that the male: female ratio was 1: 1.19, with a slight predominance of female cases. It is possible that gender differences are related to the age of the patients. For example, 24 male and 18 female patients were under 11 years old, a male: female ratio of 1.33: 1. In contrast, 21 male and 33 female patients were between 11–13 years old, a male: female ratio of 1: 1.57.

Our findings of age and gender differences of psychogenic fever patients in Japan differ from those from the United States, where psychogenic fever is most likely to occur in young women, especially women from 20 to 40 years old 636465.

Prevalence

This study also revealed that psychogenic fever is not uncommon in the clinical setting and that patients with psychogenic fever are seen in a variety of departments. Psychogenic fever accounted for 18% of FUO in children and 2–6% of outpatients who visited psychosomatic pediatrics and child psychiatry. In spite of the high rates, the prevalence of psychogenic fever has yet to be investigated. Thus, further study is needed.

Diagnosis

It is well known that psychological stress increases Tc in mammals 66. For example, cage change or removal of mice that were housed in the same cage induced a 1.5–2.0°C increase in Tc in mice 67. This phenomenon is called psychological stress-induced hyperthermia (PSH) in the field of basic science. This phenomenon is also observed in humans [for review, see 66]. In most cases, however, the increased Tc rarely exceeds the upper limit of normal temperature and disabling physical symptoms are not observed. The reasons are still uncertain as to why psychogenic fever patients have high temperature caused by psychological stress and complain of numerous physical symptoms. In the clinical papers we reviewed, psychogenic fever refers to an acute or persistent increase in Tc above the normal limits (in most cases, 37°C). Animal studies have demonstrated that the mechanisms of PSH are different from those that cause inflammation-induced "fever" 666768. Therefore, although the term "psychogenic fever" is widely used, there is room for discussion of whether the term "fever" is appropriate.

Conclusion

Psychogenic fever patients ranged from 3 to 56 years old, with the highest number of cases occurring at 13 years in both sexes. The male: female ratio of 1 : 1.19 suggests a slight predominance of female cases. Although Japanese psychogenic fever patients were mostly seen in the department of pediatrics, patients were also observed in a variety of departments, including psychosomatic medicine, psychiatry, and internal medicine.

Competing interests

The author(s) declare that they have no competing interests.

Authors' contributions

TO reviewed the papers and drafted the manuscript. KO reviewed the papers and analyzed the data. All authors read and approved the final manuscript.

Acknowledgements

This study was supported in part by a Grant-in-Aid for Scientific Research from the Japan Society for the Promotion of Science (no. 17590606 to T.O.).

Shininseihatsunetsu ni tsuite Kudo Y Koike J Jpn Med J 1965 2142 6 9 On psychogenic fever Kuramitsu M Yamaura K Kyushu-sinkei-seishin-iagku 1966 12 329 339 A case of psychogenic fever Watanabe K Miyata T Shouni-no-seishin-to-shinkei 1970 10 57 61 Geninfumei no hatsunetsu wo shimeshita 1 shorei Yamashiro Y Ootsuka S Majima T Jyuntendo Igaku 1972 17 507 512 Shininseihatsunetsu Imada Y Oono Y Jpn J Clin Exp Med 1973 50 2836 2840 Shoni shininseihatsunetsu no 1 rei Takada T Shonika Rinsho 1975 28 1331 1335 Shoni no shininseihatsunetsu Ogawa M Ueda M Iwase K Yoshida M Kumagai T Goto K Kato T Mori O Miwa K Shonika Rinsho 1978 31 818 824 Shininseihatsunetsu Mimura A Shonika 1980 21 116 Psychogenic fever – the implication of its symptoms: the parent-child relationship in the case of a 10-year-old boy Komamatsu J Abe M Miyashita H Kangogaku Zasshi 1982 46 418 423 6918527 Shininseihatsunetsu ni tsuiteno seishinbyorigakuteki kosatsu Wakimoto K Kaku R Kawamura H Hanada M Jidoseinenseishinigaku to Sono Kinseturyoiki 1983 24 29 30 Shininseihatsunetsu no H ko Suzuki M Kenkokyoshitsu 1983 34 106 111 A psychosomatic study on the children of school refusal with fever Watanabe J Okamoto M Nakagawa K Matsumoto K Yoshida T Shinshin-Igaku (Jpn J Psychosom Med) 1984 24 103 110 Kodomo no shinshinsho (sono 15) Shininseihatsunetsu Umegaki H Kenkokyoshitsu 1984 35 20 23 Shininseihatsunetsu no 10 shorei Hori M Nishimoto K Asako K Mimura A Saitamaken Igakukaizasshi 1984 18 821 Shininseihatsunetsu wo mitometa 1 jyoji rei Kozaki T Kitajyo Y Koyasu H Harada K Nakamura H Hayakawa Y Tsuda K Shinshin-Igaku (Jpn J Psychosom Med) 1984 24 362 Shininseihatsunetsu no 27 rei Kinoshita T Hirota Y Miyazawa W Miyazaki M Shimizu T Kawano T Shinozuka T Nihon Shonikagakkai Zasshi 1985 89 2565 Shininseihatsunetsu no 1 rei Sakura S Kosaka Y Asano M Saito Y Dehara I Kaneko M Kajitani H Sumita R Rinsho Masui 1985 9 1506 1508 A case of psychogenic fever Komoto J Yasumoto I Okayama Onsen-kenkyuusho Houkoku 1985 5 5 8 Shinshinsho tokunishininseihatsunetsu wo teishita shorei ni tsuite Matuhashi Y Kurokawa Y Akiyama Y Nihon Shonikagakkai Zasshi 1986 90 550 Jidouki noshininseihatsunetsu ni tsuite Ichikawa M Uemura Y Matushita E Oohara K Seishin Shinkeigaku Zasshi 1986 6 461 Pentazocine izonsho to shininseihatsunetsu Ito T Kawabata M Suda T Kosui K Suzuki T Nakajima N Torii Y Tokyo Ikadaigaku Zasshi 1986 44 754 757 Shinshinsho to binetsu-shininseihatsunetsu wo cyushin ni Katsura T J Clin Exp Med 1986 138 952 954 Shininseihatsunetsu wo shuso to shita tokokyohisho no 1 rei Harada M Iijima K Shinshin-Igaku (Jpn J Psychosom Med) 1986 26 519 Iwayuru geninfumei no hatsunetsu Hashira S Yoshino K Shoni Naika 1987 19 77 82 Shininseihatsunetsu no 2 rei ni tsuite Morikawa Y Hanayasu H Aoki S Nohara R Nishio T Sai O Izumi H Miyoshi K Mizuta T Nihon Shonikagakkai Zasshi 1987 91 1017 Shininseihatsunetsu no 4 rei-"ijime" tono kanren nitsuite Matsumoto M Oka A Shibuya K Wakita K Sakurai Y Matumoto T Hata K Nihon Shonikagakkai Zasshi 1988 92 1033 Tenkeiteki na shininseihatsunetsu wo tomonatta tokokyohisho no 1 rei Kyutoku S Kyutoku T Komiya Y Kyutoku S Mori K Tujikawa K Obo T Ito T Mori M Nihon Shonikagakkai Zasshi 1988 92 2459 Studies of psychosomatic diseases in childhood (I) : Experiences with psychosomatic diseases over a period of 17 years Saito H Yamamoto T Wada Y Ishikawa M Nihon Shonikagakkai Zasshi 1989 93 1348 1352 Process of play therapy for a child with a psychogenic fever Nakamura H Saito K Chibakenritsu-eiseitankidaigaku Kiyou 1989 8 31 38 Studies on the usefulness of Kampo medicines for psychogenic fever Oka T Mishima N Nakagawa T Oka K J Jpn Assoc Oriental Psychosom Med 1991 6 32 36 Shinshin igaku teki approach wo hodokoshita shisynki shininseihatsunetsu no 2 syorei Kikuchi H Arakawa F Matsuda M Takaoka K Shinshin-Igaku (Jpn J Psychosom Med) 1991 31 161 Shininseihatsunetsu Ihara N Shoni Naika 1991 23 suppl 296 299 "Hatsunetsu" ga kazoku system wo henka saseta shininseihatsunetsu no 1 rei Tada H Ootsuka H Umezu R Kinoshita T Murata M Nihon Shonikagakkai Zasshi 1993 97 504 Psychosomatic diseases in adolescence Ushijima S Shinshin-Igaku (Jpn J Psychosom Med) 1994 34 213 218 Shininseihatsunetsuji nokango. Kokoro sain wo do hikidashite ikuka Ariga Y Maruyama M Hirasawa K Kangojissen no Kagaku 1994 19 88 91 Therapy of Hasegawa's predicate recording method for children with psychosomatic disease and Kindergarten refusal Aihara R Kawahito M Yuasa Y Tanaka H Nihon Shonikagakkai Zasshi 1994 98 1717 1723 The application of Hasegawa's predicaterecording method for childhood psychosomatic diseases – Vth report: Investigation of an independent word Aihara R Nihon Shonikagakkai Zasshi 1994 98 1862 1868 Shininseihatsunetsu to omowareru 1 jyoji rei Hikima A Shimizu S Shonika Rinsho 1995 48 1121 1124 A case report of psychogenic fever which appeared at each visit to the dental clinic Matsuura Y Higashi M Matsun T Takei K Maeda T Shoni Shikagaku Zasshi 1995 33 792 799 Shininseihatsunetsu Sugahara H Oka T Kubo C Jpn J Clin Exp Med 1995 72 2446 2449 Kounetsu wo teishita shininseihatsunetsu ga utagawareru shoni rei Hineno H Hisajyu M Ehime Igaku 1997 16 441 Shininseihatsunetsu ga utagawareta 1 shorei Nishihara K Masuda A Kukita T Koriyama N Naruo T Nozoe S Tanaka H Shinshin-Igaku (Jpn J Psychosom Med) 1997 37 552 Futoko ni shininseihatsunetsu wo gappei shita 13 sai jyoji rei Takemura O Tanaka Y Takida K Inoue S Koritsu Yashika Byoin-shi 1997 6 109 113 A Case of psychogenic fever effectively treated with Rikkunshi-to. – Significance of taking underlying "Ki-kyo" into account for the treatment of psychosomatic disorders Oka T Araki T Oka K Kanemitsu Y Azuma T Akamine M Matsuura T Kubo C J Jpn Assoc Oriental Psychosom Med 1998 13 74 78 Shininseihatsunetsu Okazaki T Shoni-shinshinigaku Handbook Kyoto: Kitaoji-shobo Shimizu B 1999 174 179 Tandospirone ga yuko tokangaerareta shininseihatsunetsu no 1 rei Kura N Oka T Kubo C Jpn J Psychosom Med 2000 40 570 Kaiga ryoho ga yuko deatta shininseihatsunetsu no 1 rei Akamine M Araki T Oka T Kubo C Jpn J Psychosom Med 2000 40 570 A case of psychogenic fever who showed marked improvement by sandplay therapy Hidaka N Tanaka H Tsuchida K Terashima S Jpn J Psychosom Med 2001 41 55 59 A case of psychogenic fever Iimori H Ishizuka T Koizumi M Shinryonaika 2002 6 39 45 Konenkishogai ni gappei shita shininseibinetsu no byotai to schiryo ni kansuru toyoigakuteki kento Shimizu M Hara K Sugiyama T Sanfujinka-Kampo-Kenkyu-no-Ayumi 2002 19 102 105 Shininseihatsunetsu ni paroxetine hydrochloride ga yuko de atta shisyunki no 1 rei Hirakawa K Nishimura R Shiraishi K Kyusyu-shinkei-seishin-igaku 2003 49 200 Effect of Kampo medicines on psychogenic fever in childhoodand adolescence Oka T Mori H Tamagawa Y Mera T Kodama N Tsuji S Oka K J Jpn Assoc Oriental Psychosom Med 2003 18 232 237 A case of low grade fever: Does psychological stress cause fever? Oka T Kura N Kokoro-no-rinsho a la carte 2003 22 suppl 4 47 49 A case of psychogenetic fever treated successfully with art therapy Araki T Oka T Oyama N Akamine M Kubo C Jpn J Psychosom Med 2004 44 289 295 A case of psychogenetic fever treated successfully with tandospirone in combination with psychotherapy and autogenic training Kura N Oka T Ando T Ishikawa T Kubo C Ago Y Jpn J Psychosom Med 2004 44 297 303 Konenki ni okeru stress to Kampo chiryo no yakuwari Oka T Tamagawa Y Hayashida S Tuji S Sanfujinka-Kampo-Kenkyu-no-Ayumi 2004 21 30 34 Shininseihatsunetsu no 3 rei Hamada R Mameita R Sugino S Ishizaki Y Kino M Nakano H Kodomo-no-Kokoro-to-Karada 2004 13 90 Brief Consultation to psychogenic fever in an elementary school Yoshida K Wakashima K Jpn J Clin Psychol 2005 5 513 522 Mechanism and treatment of psychogenic fever Oka T Jpn J Psychosom Intern Med 2005 9 117 121 Efficacy of paroxetine for treating chronic stress-induced low-grade fever Oka T Kaneda Y Takenaga M Hayashida S Tamagawa Y Kodama N Hashimoto T Tsuji S Jpn J Psychosom Intern Med 2006 10 5 8 Why do chronic stress-induced hyperthermia patients worry about slightly elevated body temperature? Oka T Hayashida S Kaneda Y Kodama N Hashimoto T Tsuji T Jpn J Psychosom Intern Med 2006 10 243 246 A case of low-grade fever possibly induced by psychological stress and effectively treated with fluvoxamine maleate Kaneda Y Oka T Hashimoto T Tsuji S Shinryonaika 2006 10 349 353 Long continued, low grade, idiopathic fever Kintner AR Rowntree LG JAMA 1934 102 889 892 Fever of unexplained origin: report on 100 cases Petersdorf RG Beeson PB Medicine (Baltimore) 1961 40 1 30 13734791 Clinically benign fever of unknown origin: a personal retrospective Weinstein L Rev Infect Dis 1985 7 692 699 4059757 Mechanisms and mediators of psychological stress-induced rise in core temperature Oka T Oka K Hori T Psychosom Med 2001 63 476 486 11382276 Characteristics of thermoregulatory and febrile responses in mice deficient in prostaglandin EP1 and EP3 receptors Oka T Oka K Kobayashi T Sugimoto Y Ichikawa A Ushikubi F Narumiya S Saper CB J Physiol (Lond) 2003 551 945 954 10.1113/jphysiol.2003.048140 12837930 Prostaglandin E2 as a mediator of fever: the role of prostaglandin E (EP) receptors Oka T Frontiers in Bioscience 2004 9 3046 57 10.2741/1458 15353336