Background
The neuropathological features of Alzheimer's disease (AD) include neurofibrillary tangles (NFT), deposition of amyloid-β (Aβ) in senile plaques, and neuronal loss in affected brain regions 1. The Aβ is cleaved from the amyloid precursor protein (APP) by the β- and γ-secretases 234, and is believed to play an important role in the onset and progression of AD 56. Accordingly, many of the strategies currently being proposed as therapies for AD are aimed at reducing the level of Aβ in the brain, and/or preventing the assembly of this peptide into pathological forms. One potentially powerful strategy for reducing the level of Aβ in the brain is immunotherapy, in which antibodies specific for Aβ facilitate the clearance amyloid deposits and a reduction in other forms Aβ in the brain parenchyma. Both active and passive Aβ-immunotherapy significantly decrease amyloid deposits, neuritic dystrophy and gliosis in the brain, as well as improve behavioural measures in APP/Tg mice 789101112. Based on these and other studies in several animal models, the AN-1792 clinical trial was initiated in patients with mild-to-moderate AD, however the trial was halted during the phase II portion of the trial when approximately 6% of the AD patients vaccinated with AN1792 developed meningoencephalitis and in some cases CAA associated haemorrhages. The cause of the encephalitis in these patients has not yet been determined, however speculation has focused on autoreactive T-cells and the proinflammatory Th1 type of adjuvant that was used in the clinical trial 13141516. Of note, there is only one unconfirmed report about lymphocyte infiltration detected in the brains of wildtype mice immunized with Aβ42 formulated in FCA/FIA followed by injection with pertussis toxin 17. In addition to T cell infiltration into the brain parenchyma, another participant in the clinical trial developed widespread cortical hemorrhages 16. Microhemorrhages in the cerebral vasculature have also been observed in different strains of very old (21–26 month-old) APP/Tg mice injected weekly with high doses of anti-Aβ monoclonal antibodies, and the sites of microhemorrhage have been co-localized with cerebral vascular Aβ deposits 18192021. Recently, it was reported that active immunizations of APP/Tg mice with fibrillar Aβ42 formulated in a strong conventional adjuvant, Freund's complete adjuvant system (FCA), could also increase microhemorrhages in the brains of vaccinated animals 22. Collectively, these adverse events emphasized the need for further refinement of vaccines for AD in order to eliminate, or at least attenuate, the potential adverse events initiated by infiltration of autoreactive T cells and peripheral macrophages, as well as inflammation-induced cerebral vascular microhemorrhages.
Mannan and other polysaccharides are recognized by collectins, such as, Mannose-Binding Lectin (MBL) 232425, as well as Mannose Binding Receptors (MBRs) expressed on dendritic cells, some endothelial cells and macrophages 26272829. After binding to mannan, MBL initiates the complement pathway via an activation of the MASP-1 & MASP-2 proteases, and is antibody- and C1q-independent. Therefore, immunization of mice with Aβ peptide sequences conjugated to mannan should induce complement activation and C3d opsonization on the Aβ. Moreover, MBL, which also has opsonic function like complement C1q (homologue of MBL), binds to complement receptor type 1 (CR1/CD35) 30 and therefore stimulates phagocytosis of the conjugated antigen. Finally, T-cell dependent B-cell immune responses can be activated not only by simultaneous triggering of BCR and C' receptor type 2 (CD21), but also by simultaneous triggering of BCR and C' receptor type 1 (CD35) 3132. Importantly, different groups have already demonstrated enhancement of T-helper and B-cell immune responses against several mannosylated-antigens, including peptide-antigens 333435. In addition to the direct activation of C', Aβ-mannan conjugates will be recognized by MBRs found on dendritic cells, some endothelial cells and macrophages 262728. The macrophage mannose receptor (MMR) and DEC-205 found on dendritic and some endothelial cells bind multiple carbohydrates 36. These receptors significantly enhance phagocytosis of antigens containing an appropriate carbohydrate, such as mannose residues. In addition, the receptors can also increase antigen presentation on macrophages and dendritic cells by 100- to 1,000-fold over antigens without carbohydrate residues. Thus, besides activating complement, Aβ conjugated to mannan will also promote phagocytosis and antigen presentation on macrophages and dendritic cells of the immune system, providing an added benefit from the conjugation of mannan to Aβ. Notably, under certain conditions, mannosylated antigens induced strong Th2-type anti-inflammatory responses (production of IL4/IL10 cytokines) with high levels of IgG1 antibodies 33343738.
Previously, we generated mannan-Aβ28 conjugate and demonstrated that immunization of wild-type mice with this vaccine enhanced the production of IL4 (Th2-type) cytokine followed by generation of antibodies specific to the self-Aβ antigen 39. Here for the first time we tested the safety and efficacy of mannan-Aβ28 conjugate in Tg2576 mouse model of AD. We demonstrated that, in the absence of any conventional adjuvant, mannan-Aβ28 conjugate enhanced the production of Th2-type anti-Aβ antibodies inhibiting Aβ plaque formation. However, the mannan-peptide conjugate induced higher levels of microhemorrhages compared to that in the brains of age-matched control animals.
Methods
Preparation of mannan-Aβ28 immunoconjugate
Mannan (Saccharomyces cerevisiae, Sigma, MO) was purified by passage over a Q Sepharose FF column (GE Healthcare) to remove residual nucleic acid. Mannan was activated 40 and conjugated to Aβ28 peptide, as previously described39. In brief, a 10 mg/ml solution of mannan was activated by addition of the organic cyanylating reagent 1-cyano-4-dimethylaminopyridinium tetrafluoroborate (CDAP) (25 μl/ml, 100 mg/ml in acetonitrile). After 30 sec, 25 μl/ml of aqueous 0.2 M triethylamine (TEA) was added. After another 2 min an equal volume of 0.5 M hexanediamine, pH 9, was added and the reaction allowed to proceed overnight and then dialyzed against water. The mannan concentration and the free amine content were determined as previously described 40. The amino-mannan was bromoacetylated using NHS bromoacetate, and desalted by dialysis. Aβ28 peptide (5.0 mg/ml) with an N-terminal linker (n-CAGA) sequence synthesized by (Multiple Peptide Systems, San Diego, CA) was dissolved in 0.15 M HEPES, 2 mM EDTA, pH 7.3, and the free thiol content determined using Ellman's reagent. The peptide was combined with the bromoacetylated mannan at a molar ratio of 30 thiols/100 kDa of carbohydrate under a stream of nitrogen. After an overnight reaction, the solution was quenched by the addition of mercaptoethanol concentrated with an Ultra 4 (10 kDa cut-off) device (Millipore, MA), and free peptide removed by gel filtration on a Sepharose 12 column (GE Healthcare, NJ), equilibrated with 0.1 M HEPES, pH 8. The void volume peak was pooled. The peptide content was determined from the UV spectrum and its calculated extinction coefficient. The final product contained 50 μM peptide at a ratio of 5 moles of peptide per 100 kDa of mannan formulated in PBS.
To generate a control mannan-antigen conjugate, mannan was coupled with BSA via a thiol-ether linkage as described for Aβ28 peptide except that the reaction was quenched with ethanolamine before gel filtration on a S300HR column (GE Healthcare, NJ). The peak tube from the void volume was assayed by the Bradford method using BioRad protein reagent, with BSA as the standard. Finally, biotinylated mannan was prepared by reaction of biotin-NHS with the amino-mannan, and un-reacted biotin was removed by gel filtration.
Immunization of mice and detection of anti-Aβ and anti-mannan antibodies
Based on our results with wild-type mice 39, we immunized young 4–4.5 mo-old Tg2576 (APPsw) mice [Tg (HuAPP695.K670N/M671L) 2576] 4142 without pre-existing AD-like pathology 43, (n = 8, 3 males, 5 females), six times biweekly with 10 μg/mouse of mannan-Aβ28 conjugate, subcutaneously (s.c.). Control mice of the same age were either injected 6 times s.c. with mannan-BSA conjugate (n = 6, 3 males, 3 females), or remained non-immunized (n = 5, 2 males, 3 females). We collected sera on the 9th day after the last injection, or at the end of the resting period (~11 months), and examined the humoral immune responses by ELISA. Anti-Aβ antibodies and their isotypes were detected in individual sera as previously described 39444546. Of note, concentrations of anti-Aβ antibodies were calculated using a standard curve generated with 6E10 monoclonal antibody (Signet, MA). Also, using a similar ELISA technique we detected the titers of anti-mannan antibodies, although in these experiments streptavidin pre-coated plate wells (Express Biotech International, MD) were coated with 2 μg/ml biotinylated mannan as recommended by manufacturer before addition of immune or control sera.
Dot blot assay
Binding of anti-Aβ28 antibody to different forms of Aβ42 peptide was demonstrated as described 47. Briefly, 1 μl of monomeric, oligomeric or fibrillar forms of Aβ42 (45 μM each) were applied to a nitrocellulose membrane. After blocking and washing, the membranes were probed with sera from mice immunized with mannan-BSA, mannan-Aβ28 (1 μg/ml), anti-Aβ 20.1 monoclonal (1 μg/ml) antibody, or rabbit A11 polyclonal (1 μg/ml) antibody previously described by 48. The membranes were incubated with appropriate HRP-conjugated anti-mouse (1:2000) or anti-rabbit (1:2000) antibody (Santa Cruz Biotechnology, CA). Blots were developed using Luminol reagent (Santa Cruz Biotechnology, CA) and exposed to Kodak X-Omat AR film.
Immunohistochemistry
After the termination of the study, we obtained the brains of experimental and control mice (~18–18.5 months) and analyzed the impact of active immunization with mannan-Aβ28 on neuropathological changes as we previously described 474950 Briefly, mice were halothane-anesthetized, perfused with PBS prior to removing the brains. Brains were fixed (4% paraformaldehyde, 48 hrs), and brain tissues were sectioned (40 μm thick) and stored at 4°C (PBS with 0.02% sodium azide). Staining of duplicates of coronal sections of experimental and control mouse brains, collected from 3 different planes of the brain about 1 mm apart, with monoclonal anti-Aβ40 or Aβ42 (Signet, MA) as we described 49.
The quantitative analysis of CAA was made as described by 51. Briefly, CAA score (based on frequency and severity) was quantified on the sections immunostained with anti-Aβ40 throughout the neocortex. Six sections from each brain in the groups of mice immunized with mannan-Aβ28, mannan-BSA or non-immunized animals were analyzed. CAA frequency was calculated by counting the total number of Aβ-positive vessels in the set of sampled sections, while CAA severity was assessed using three severity grades: grade 1, Aβ immunoreactivity confined strictly to the vessel wall; grade 2, Aβ immunoreactivity in and around vessel wall with focal infiltration of the amyloid in the neuropil; and grade 3, extensive infiltration of amyloid into the neuropil with a complete amyloid coat around the vessel. The mean for all vessels was taken as CAA severity, and final CAA score was calculated by multiplying CAA frequency with CAA severity. All of the quantitations were done on both hemispheres by two independent investigators and yielded similar results.
Binding of the pooled immune sera from the group of mice immunized with mannan- Aβ28 to the 50 μm brain section of formalin-fixed cortical tissue of a 75-year-old woman with neuropathological and behavioural patterns typical to severe AD, was done as we described previously 4547. To demonstrate the specificity of binding of anti- Aβ28 antibodies to the brain tissue we blocked antisera from immune mice with the Aβ1–15 peptide at 5 μM concentration as described 47.
For detection of astrocytosis, we used cow glial fibrillary acidic protein, GFAP (DAKO, Denmark). To detect microgliosis, we used anti-mouse CD45 (LCA, Ly-5, Pharmingen, CA). Anti-C1q and anti-C3b antibodies (eBioscience, CA) were used to detect activation of complement as previously described 52. Infiltration of T cells was analyzed using anti-CD3-ε (Santa Cruz Biotechnology, CA) antibody. The tissues from all animals within a given experimental group were processed in parallel. Hydrogen peroxide-quenched and blocked sections were incubated with primary antibody overnight at 4°C. Sections were then washed and incubated with appropriate biotinylated secondary antibodies against corresponding species. Colour developed via ABC and DAB (3,3'-diaminobenzidine) substrate kits (Vector, CA). Images of the immunostaining were captured using a Sony high-resolution CCD video camera (XC-77), and quantification of staining was performed using NIH image 1.59b5 software. For every animal, eighteen images (525 × 410 μm each) of the frontal parietal region in the cortex area of 2 adjacent sections were captured with 20× objective. Samples consisted of nine images from the superficial layer and the remaining nine from the deep layer. NIH imaging was used to analyze the area occupied by amyloid plaques, as well as CD45- and GFAP-immunoreactivity. The threshold for the detection of immunoreactivity was established and then held constant throughout the image analysis. Additionally, we performed a visual inspection of hippocampal and cortical regions of all stained sections in a blinded fashion (observer had no knowledge of the treatment group); a mean semi-quantitative score was independently determined for each slide by 2 observers.
Histochemistry
Determination of cored plaques was accessed using Thioflavin-S (ThS) according to a standard protocol from the IBAD, UCI. Briefly, sections from immunized and control animals were mounted on Vectabond-coated slides (Vector Labs, CA). Sections were then washed with Tris buffer (0.1 M Tris buffered saline at pH 7.5) and stained with 0.5% ThS (Sigma, MO) in 50% ethanol for 10 min. Finally, sections were washed in 50% ethanol, and twice in Tris buffer, then dried and coverslipped with Vectashield (Vector Labs, CA). ThS-positive plaques were counted by visual inspection of cortical and hippocampal regions of all stained sections in a blinded fashion; a mean semi-quantitative score was independently determined for each slide by 2 observers.
Determination of microhemorrhages was performed using Prussian blue staining of ferric acid according to a standard protocol from IBAD, UCI. Briefly, duplicates of coronal sections of experimental and control mouse brains, 40 μm thick, collected from 3 different planes of the brain (about 1 mm apart), were mounted on Vectabond coated slides (Vector Labs, CA) and stained with Prussian blue working solution, a mixture of freshly made 5% Potassium hexacyanoferrate (II) trihydrate, and 5% hydrochloric acid (all from Sigma, MO). After 30 min all sections were rinsed in water, counterstained with Nuclear Fast Red (Sigma, MO), dehydrated and covered using DPX (BDH Laboratory Supplies, England). The hemorrhage profiles (hemosiderin stain) were counted by two independent observers, and the average number of Prussian blue-positive deposits was calculated for each brain section.
For detection of co-localization of Aβ accumulation and complement markers in vasculature we used combination of two methods described above. First, sections were glass mounted, peroxidase-quenched and stained with anti C1q and C3b antibodies (eBioscience, CA) followed by biotinylated secondary antibodies and streptavidin-Alexa Fluor 555 (Thermo Fisher Scientific, IL). After that, ThS staining was performed as described above. Confocal images were collected on an Olympus IX70 inverted microscope and a BioRad Radiance 2000 Laser Scanning System using 70× objective for image analysis.
Statistical Analysis
To assess the differences in antibody titers, plaque areas, glial immunoreactivity, frequency of microhemorrhages and CAA in experimental mice versus the control groups, a two-tailed Students's t-tests were performed using Graph Pad Prism 3.03 software.
Results
Mannan-Aβ28 immunoconjugate induced potent anti-Aβ antibody responses in the Tg2576 mouse model of AD
Previously, we have demonstrated that 10 μg of human mannan-Aβ28 peptide conjugate enhanced Th2 type anti-Aβ antibody production in wild-type mice39. In the current study we first analyzed the immunogenicity of mannan-Aβ28 immunoconjugate in the Tg2576 mouse model of AD in which Aβ28 is a self-antigen. After six biweekly immunizations with the same low dose (10 μg) of mannan-Aβ28 antigen, 5 out of 8 Tg2576 mice generated robust anti-Aβ antibody production, whereas the remaining mice expressed less than 5 μg/ml of antibodies (Figure 1A). Average anti-Aβ antibody concentrations were 10.4 μg/ml, equal to titers of ≥ 1:10,000. The humoral immune response generated by the mannan-Aβ28 immunogen was long lasting since the anti-Aβ antibody concentration remained readily detectable (0.8 μg/ml or approximately a titer of ≥ 1:800) in vaccinated animals that were held free of immunizations for 11 months (Figure 1A). Antibody isotyping can be used as an indirect measure of the contribution of Th1 (IgG2a) and Th2 (IgG1) cytokines to the humoral response53. Additionally, the subclass of anti-Aβ antibodies may correlate with their therapeutic potential1154. Thus, we measured the production of IgG1, IgG2ab, IgG2b, and IgM anti-Aβ antibodies in the sera of vaccinated Tg2576 mice, demonstrating that mannan-Aβ28 induced predominantly IgG1, although two mice also produced significant amount of IgM antibody (Figure 1B). Interestingly, the isotypic profile of anti-Aβ antibodies was similar at 9 days and 11 months after the last boost (Figure 1B), and the ratios of IgG1 to IgG2ab antibody in these mice were 8.2 and 5.25, respectively. Thus, immunization with the Aβ28 immunoconjugate induced long-lasting therapeutically potent anti-Aβ antibodies in Tg2576 mice, and the humoral immune response was Th2-polarized, similar to the observations after the conjugation of mannan with other peptide immunogens 333738 or immunizations of wildtype mice with mannan-Aβ2839.
<p>Figure 1</p>
Mannan-Aβ28 immunoconjugate induces potent levels of anti-Aβ and low levels of anti-mannan antibodies in Tg2576 mice
Mannan-Aβ28 immunoconjugate induces potent levels of anti-Aβ and low levels of anti-mannan antibodies in Tg2576 mice. A. Vaccinated mice 7–7.5 months of age produced on average 10.4 μg/ml of anti-Aβ antibodies (approximate titers ≥ 1:10,000) after 6 immunizations. At termination, when mice reached 18–18.5 months of age they still produced low levels of anti-Aβ antibodies (0.8 μg/ml or approximate titers ≥ 1:800). Noteworthy, mice immunized with mannan-BSA did not produce detectable levels of anti-Aβ antibodies (data not shown). B. Mannan-Aβ28 induced primarily IgG1 isotype antibodies, indicative of a Th2 type humoral immune response before resting period (sera were collected on 9th day after the last boost) and after resting period (sera were collected after 11 months). One vaccinated mouse also induced high level of IgM anti-Aβ antibodies. C. After 6 injections vaccinated mice produced low titers of anti-mannan antibodies. Of note, the titers of anti-mannan antibodies dropped dramatically during the intervening 11 months following the final injection (data not shown). (D). Mannan-Aβ28 as well as mannan-BSA induced only low levels of anti-mannan antibodies predominantly of IgG and IgM isotypes in mice immunized with mannan-Aβ28, and IgG isotypes for mice immunized with mannan-BSA. E. Anti-Aβ28 antibodies bind to all species of Aβ42 peptide. One μl of Aβ42 fibrils, oligomers and monomers (45 μM each) were applied in duplicate to a nitrocellulose membrane and probed with sera from mannan-BSA immunized mice (control), sera from mice immunized with mannan-Aβ28, anti-Aβ 20.1 monoclonal antibody and rabbit A11 antibody shown to bind oligomeric forms of Aβ42. (F). Binding of immune mannan-Aβ28 sera to the AD brain section. Binding of antisera was blocked by Aβ1–15 peptide. Original magnification, 20×, scale bar = 100 μm.
![]()
Mannan was previously shown to be a weak T-independent antigen, however because the mannan was conjugated to a peptide (Aβ) or a protein (BSA), both of which contain T helper cell epitopes that can be used to promote the production of anti-mannan antibodies, we analyzed the antibody response to mannan induced by immunizations with mannan-Aβ28 or mannan-BSA conjugates. As we expected, both groups of mice induced only low titers of anti-mannan antibodies at day 9 after the last boost (Figure 1C). The anti-mannan antibodies were of the IgG and IgM isotypes in mice immunized with mannan-Aβ28 and predominantly of IgG isotypes in mice immunized with mannan-BSA (Figure 1D). It was not surprising that both immunoconjugates induced IgG anti-mannan antibodies because Aβ28 44 and BSA possess T helper epitope/s that make mannan-peptide/protein conjugate a T-dependent antigen.
In the light of recent data that oligomeric forms of Aβ42 peptide are the most toxic forms, we analyzed the binding ability of immune and control sera to Aβ monomers, oligomers and fibrils by a dot blot assay. Sera from mannan-Aβ28 immunized, but not from mannan-BSA immunized mice, bound to all forms of Aβ42, although binding was better to the monomeric and oligomeric forms than to fibrillar Aβ42 (Figure 1E). We also demonstrated that immune sera bound to Aβ plaques in the brain tissue from an AD clinical case. This binding was specific since pre-incubation of sera with the Aβ1–15 peptide resulted in its complete inhibition (Figure 1F).
Immunization with mannan-Aβ28 inhibits AD-like amyloid pathology in the brain
Next, we analyzed the extent of AD-like pathology in brains of vaccinated Tg2576 mice (18–18.5 months old). As controls, we used Tg2576 mice of the same age injected with mannan-BSA, or non-immunized group of animals. Image analysis of anti-Aβ40 and anti-Aβ42 antibody-stained parietal cortical sections demonstrated a significant reduction of amyloid plaques in brains of mice vaccinated with mannan-Aβ28 compared with similar brain staining of non-immunized mice (Figure 2) or animals injected with mannan-BSA (data not shown). While staining with anti-Aβ40 and anti-Aβ42 antibodies detected both cored and diffuse plaques, ThS binds only to cored amyloid deposits. Therefore, we compared image analyses with ThS staining of parietal cortical brain sections from vaccinated and control Tg2576 mice. We found that mice actively immunized 11 months earlier with the mannan-Aβ28 conjugate had significantly reduced depositions of cored amyloid plaques (Figure 2D). A similar reduction in Aβ40 and Aβ42 amyloid burden, as well as cored plaques was observed in the hippocampus of vaccinated mice compared with control non-immunized animals (Figure 2A). Of note, we observed no changes in Aβ depositions by immunohistochemistry or histochemistry in the brains of mice immunized 6 times with mannan-BSA compared to non-immunized control (data not shown). Collectively, these results demonstrate that the mannan-Aβ28 immunogen induced therapeutically potent anti-Aβ antibodies, predominantly of the IgG1 isotype, that effectively reduced the deposition AD-like plaque pathology in 18–18.5 months old Tg2576 mice.
<p>Figure 2</p>
Vaccination with mannan-Aβ28 attenuates amyloid deposition in the cortical and hippocampal regions of brains
Vaccination with mannan-Aβ28 attenuates amyloid deposition in the cortical and hippocampal regions of brains. A. Representative images of hippocampal region from non-immunized controls and mice immunized with mannan-Aβ28 showing reduction of Aβ42 and Aβ40 amyloid burden or cored amyloid plaques. Aβ deposits were stained with anti-Aβ42, anti-Aβ40 antibodies, and with ThS. Original magnifications, 5× for anti-Aβ42/40 staining and 4× for ThS (scale bars = 200 μm). B, C, D. Image analysis of Aβ42 (B), Aβ40 (C) staining, and number of ThS-positive cored plaques (D) in cortex of 18–18.5 mo old Tg2576 non-immunized mice and mice immunized with mannan-Aβ28. Vaccinated mice showed significant reduction in Aβ42 (P = 0.0075), Aβ40 (P = 0.0103) burden, and in number of ThS-positive cored plaques (P = 0.0019) compared to that in non-immunized control group. Bars represent mean ± SE from n = 5 in the group of non-immunized mice, and n = 8 in the group of mice immunized with mannan-Aβ28.
![]()
Immunizations with mannan-Aβ28 reduced glial activation in brains of Tg2576 mice
It was previously reported that following active and passive Aβ-immunotherapy, microglia activation in brains of aged APP/Tg mice was attenuated 5556575859. In the current study, we investigated the relationship between a reduction in fibrillar amyloid deposition and the state of microglial activation in the brains of Tg2576 mice. After eleven months mannan-Aβ28 vaccination there was significantly less microglia activation as detected both in the frontal cortex and in the hippocampus using anti-CD45 antibody immunostaining and image analysis (Figure 3A, C). In fact, in the hippocampus areas of vaccinated mice we detected only a few cells weakly stained for CD45, while similar brain areas of the age-matched non-immunized Tg2576 mice (Figure 3C) or mannan-BSA (data not shown) were stained intensively for CD45.
<p>Figure 3</p>
Effects of vaccination with mannan-Aβ28 on microglial and astrocyte activation in Tg2576 mice
Effects of vaccination with mannan-Aβ28 on microglial and astrocyte activation in Tg2576 mice. Image analysis of cortical sections performed after staining with anti-CD45 (A) and anti-GFAP (B) antibodies of brain sections from non-immunized controls and mice immunized with mannan-Aβ28. Significantly less microglial activation (P = 0.0003) and lower level of astrocytosis (P = 0.3263) were detected after immunization with mannan-Aβ28 compared to non-immunized control mice. Representative pictures of staining with anti-CD45 (C) and anti-GFAP (D) antibodies showing a decrease in immunoreactivity in hippocampal areas of brain sections of mice immunized with mannan-Aβ28 versus control non-immunized mice. Original magnifications: 5×, scale bar = 200 μm.
![]()
It was previously shown that Aβ immunotherapy may reduce neuritic dystrophy and astrogliosis, along with reversing memory deficits in mouse models of AD 116061. To determine the role of vaccination with mannan-Aβ28 in the reduction of astrocytosis, we stained brains of vaccinated and non-immunized control mice with anti-GFAP antibody. Image analyses of parietal cortical tissues demonstrated that brains of vaccinated mice were stained less robustly than those of control animals. Although, there was a trend toward less stimulation of astrogliosis, it did not reach significance in the cortex (Figure 3B), a similar trend was also observed in the hippocampus region of brains from vaccinated mice (Figure 3D).
Vaccination with mannan-Aβ28 immunoconjugate induced microhemorrhage
Previous studies have shown that passive immunotherapy with high doses of anti-Aβ antibodies may induce microhemorrhage in aged APP/Tg mice 1821. More recently, it was reported that multiple (10 times) immunizations of APP+PS1 mice with high doses of fibrillar Aβ42 formulated in conventional adjuvant (FCA/FIA) could also increase microhemorrhage in 20 months old mice 22. Interestingly, in PDAPP mice passive vaccination with anti-Aβ antibodies cleared vascular amyloid, but high doses of antibodies induced microhemorrhages that are limited to focal perivascular sites 62. Here, we analyzed microhemorrhage in 18–18.5 months-old Tg2576 mice, vaccinated with low doses of mannan-Aβ28, for 11 months prior to sacrifice, by hemosiderin staining with Prussian blue. Numbers of positive profiles per section of the brains of mannan-Aβ28 vaccinated animals were compared with that in the brains of control age-matched animals immunized with mannan-BSA, or non-immunized mice. We observed low numbers of microhemorrhage in both non-immunized and mannan-BSA injected control aged mice. In contrast, following vaccination with mannan-Aβ28, we detected significantly (P < 0.001) higher numbers of microhemorrhage (Figure 4A). Additionally, we observed larger microhemorrhage in mice vaccinated with mannan-Aβ28 (Figure 4B, C, D), than in mannan-BSA (Figure 4E, F), or non-immunized control animals (Figure 4G). Previously, it was demonstrated that passive Aβ-immunizations resulted in reduction of amyloid deposition, but also increased incidence of microhemorrhage associated with increased CAA in humans 14 and APP/Tg mice 20. Thus, we undertook a semi-quantitative analysis of the CAA in the cortical brain sections of mice injected with mannan-Aβ28, mannan-BSA, or non-immunized animals. CAA score was calculated based on the frequency and severity of the Aβ immunoreactivity confined strictly to the vessel wall, around vessel wall with focal infiltration of the amyloid in the neuropil, or extensively infiltrated into the neuropil with a complete amyloid coat around the vessel as it is shown in Figure 5A, B, C. Using this approach we calculated CAA in neocortical areas of experimental and control animals and demonstrated that the CAA score was almost equal in mice vaccinated with mannan-Aβ28, mannan-BSA or non-immunized control (P > 0.05, Figure 5D). Of note, we did not quantitate CAA in the meninges in this study, because the above mentioned standard Aβ burden measurements made in the parenchyma and normalized to brain region were not applicable to the meningeal location of vascular Aβ deposits.
<p>Figure 4</p>
The incidence and severity of vascular microhemorrhages increased following mannan-Aβ28 immunizations
The incidence and severity of vascular microhemorrhages increased following mannan-Aβ28 immunizations. A. Quantification of Prussian blue staining based on the total number of positive profiles per section for mice injected with mannan-Aβ28, mannan-BSA, or non-immunized group. The levels of microhemorrhages were increased in vaccinated Tg2576 mice (n = 8) to 6.81 ± 2.6 compared to that of 2.31 ± 0.84 in mice immunized with mannan-BSA (n = 6), and 2.07 ± 0.58 in non-immunized animals (n = 5). *** Indicates P < 0.001. B-G. Examples of microhemorrhage severity in the brain sections of mice injected with mannan-Aβ28 (B, C, D), mannan-BSA (E, F), or non-immunized animals (G). B. A focal microhemorrhage (arrow) at the cortical-subcortical junction, below the gray-white matter border, lateral to hippocampus. C. Representative images of the Prussian blue-positive blood vessels (arrows) most prominent in the meningeal, superficial parenchymal and cortical vessels. D. A focal hemorrhage in the area of anterior commissure. E. A single microhemorrhage (arrow) in the white matter region. F. Microhemorrhage-free cortical and leptomeningeal areas. G. Two microhemorrhages (arrows) in the cortical and white matter regions. Original magnification, 10×, scale bar = 100 μm.
![]()
<p>Figure 5</p>
Semi-quantitative analysis of CAA in the neocortex areas of animals immunized with mannan-Aβ28, mannan-BSA, or non-immunized mice
Semi-quantitative analysis of CAA in the neocortex areas of animals immunized with mannan-Aβ28, mannan-BSA, or non-immunized mice. A, B, C. Examples of CAA severity grades: grade 1, Aβ immunoreactivity confined strictly to the vessel wall (A); grade 2, Aβ immunoreactivity in and around vessel wall with focal infiltration of the amyloid in the neuropil (B); grade 3, extensive infiltration of amyloid into the neuropil with a complete amyloid coat around the vessel (C). Original magnification 20×, scale bar = 50 μm. D. The CAA score detected in the neocortex of mice vaccinated with mannan-Aβ28, was similar to that detected in neocortex of animals injected with mannan-BSA or non-immunized mice (P > 0.05). Bars represent mean ± SE from n = 5 in the group of non-immunized mice, n = 6 in the group of mannan-BSA immunized group, and n = 8 in the group of mice immunized with mannan-Aβ28.
![]()
Since the activation of the complement cascade by antibody-Aβ immune complexes at sites of cerebral amyloid angiopathy (CAA) may be one possible cause of microhemorrhage, it was of interest to analyze the opsonization of sites of microhemorrhage with C1q and C3 proteolytic fragments, C3b, complement components in mice immunized with mannan-Aβ28. We detected the accumulation of these complement proteins in the cerebral vasculature of immunized, but not control mice immunized with mannan-BSA (Figure 6A). In the meningeal vessels, in the group of mannan-Aβ28 immunized animals we have demonstrated partially cleared ThS-stained vascular fibrillar Aβ deposits abundantly decorated with C1q component of complement, while only trace amount of C1q was co-localized with compact Aβ load in the meninges of mannan-BSA immunized group, and practically none of the C1q was detected in the Aβ-laden meninges of non-immunized animals (Figure 6B). The similar co-localization pattern was shown for C3b component of complement (data not shown).
<p>Figure 6</p>
Immunostaining of neocortex for C1q and C3b components of complement, and concomitant staining of meninges for C1q and ThS
Immunostaining of neocortex for C1q and C3b components of complement, and concomitant staining of meninges for C1q and ThS. A. Representative images of cortex areas of coronal brain sections of mice immunized with mannan-Aβ28 or mannan-BSA, immunostained with antibodies specific for C1q and C3b components of complement. Original magnification, 20×, scale bar = 50 μm. B. Representative images of colocalization of vascular fibrillar Aβ detected with ThS (green) with C1q component of complement (red) in the meninges of coronal brain sections of mice immunized with mannan-Aβ28, mannan-BSA or non-immunized animals. Original magnification, 70×.
![]()
Discussion
Anti-Aβ immunotherapy is one strategy for the inhibition/reduction of soluble and insoluble amyloid-β deposits that likely play a causal role in the onset and progression of AD 56. Several pre-clinical studies with mouse models of AD have demonstrated the ability of Aβ vaccination to prevent amyloid deposition in the brain. Thus, active immunization with Aβ 763, as well as passive immunization intraperitoneally 11, or direct to the brain application of anti-Aβ antibodies64, resulted in reduction of the amyloid burden in the brain. Importantly, active immunizations prevented cognitive decline 89, and passive immunizations were shown to reverse the memory loss in aged Tg2576 mice 65. While these and other studies did not report any adverse events in AD mouse models immunized with fibrillar Aβ42, data from the AN-1792 vaccine trial suggest that the adverse reactions to Aβ42-immunotherapy were not due to the humoral antibody response, but rather to the cell-mediated autoimmune response, possibly exacerbated by the reformulation of adjuvant, QS21 supplemented with polysorbate-80, which induced a Th1 type immune response in patients that received the AN1792 vaccine 131415166366676869. Thus, the goal of this pre-clinical study was to employ a molecular adjuvant, mannan, that induces a Th2-type humoral immune response specific to Aβ peptide, and test the efficacy of vaccination on AD-like pathology in aged Tg2576 mice.
Previously, mannan was shown to enhance both humoral and cellular immunity against various immunogens conjugated to mannan. Multiple mechanisms likely contribute to the adjuvant properties of mannan conjugates, including activation of complement, enhancing uptake and presentation of the conjugated antigen, as well as by providing a stronger signal to antigen-specific B cells by simultaneous triggering of B-cell receptors and CD21/CD35 molecules 2627283132333435707172737475. Notably, under certain conditions mannan was shown to induce predominantly Th2 polarized anti-inflammatory immune responses to a conjugated non-self peptides 33343738, a response which would presumably be beneficial to an anti-Aβ vaccine. We previously reported that Aβ42 possesses B and T cell antigenic epitopes, both of which are contained within the Aβ28 peptide in mice 44. In addition, our previous studies in wild-type mice using mannan conjugated to Aβ28 peptide was able to induce potent and highly polarized Th2 phenotype anti-Aβ antibody responses 39. In the current study, we immunized anti-Aβ hyporesponsive Tg2576 mice with mannan-Aβ28 conjugate prior to the onset of amyloid plaque pathology in the brains of Tg2576 mice 4376. Mice were immunized six times with low doses (10 μg per mouse) of mannan-Aβ28 conjugate and the titer of anti-Aβ antibodies were assessed by ELISA. The antibodies induced by the mannan-Aβ28 conjugate were predominantly of the IgG1 isotype and elevated titers were maintained for 11 months without further immunizations (Figure 1A, B). Thus, we demonstrated that our mannan-Aβ28 immunoconjugate induced long-lasting and Th2-polarized anti-Aβ humoral immune responses in Tg2576 mice in the absence of a conventional adjuvant, such as alum or CFA. The humoral immune response induced by mannan-Aβ28 was similar to that reported after multiple injections of 5 to 10 times higher doses of fibrillar Aβ42 formulated in strong Th1 or Th2 conventional adjuvants 7844777879.
We examined the effect of mannan-Aβ28 vaccination on the neuropathology in 18–18.5 months old mice, and showed a significant reduction in both the Aβ40 and Aβ42 burden, as well as in the number of ThS positive cored plaques in the parietal cortical and hippocampal regions (Figure 2) of the brains from mice immunized 11 months earlier. Of note, previously we demonstrated that Aβ load was significantly reduced in the brains of Tg2576 mice with a high concentration of serum anti-Aβ1–11 antibody (>50 μg/ml), whereas moderate concentration (5–50 μg/ml) of this antibody resulted in a trend toward a reduction in Aβ deposits, however it did not reach significance 49. In the current study antibody specific to Aβ28 even at a moderate concentration (Figure 1A) significantly reduced both Aβ40 and Aβ42 deposits. This difference in potency of anti-Aβ antibody may be due not only to the different antigen configurations, but also to the starting point of immunization. More specifically, immunization with mannan-Aβ28 was started in mice without pre-existing pathology (preventive vaccination strategy), whereas in previous study 49 immunization was initiated in mice with established AD-like pathology (therapeutic vaccination strategy). Of note, we did not detect any CD3-positive T cells in the brains of mice immunized with mannan-Aβ28 (data not shown). Thus, inhibiting Aβ deposition in immunized Tg2576 mice was not associated with any adverse events, except for the increase in microhemorrhages.
The first two case reports from the AN-1792 clinical trial both reported meningoencephalitis with lymphocyte infiltration in the brain 1516. Additionally, the third case report demonstrated increased CAA without clinical presentation of meningoencephalitis, however there was noticeable perivascular T cell infiltration 14. It is worth mentioning, that a high degree of CAA typically indicates that hemorrhages are present in the brain 8081. However, only the case report from an AD patient from the Barcelona cohort of the AN-1792 trial found fully developed hemorrhages 16. The data on anti-Aβ immunotherapy in experimental mouse models of AD are somewhat different. Normally, rodents do not develop Aβ-CAA, except several APP transgenic mice models, including aged Tg2576 mice developing vascular amyloid in addition to the significant parenchymal amyloid 8283. Importantly, several studies with aged APP/Tg mice reported cerebral vascular microhemorrhages after passive transfer of high doses of anti-Aβ antibodies 182084. Additionally, it was shown that 3D6 antibody specific to N-terminal region of amyloid, but not antibody against Aβ16–23 (266) prevented or cleared vascular Aβ in a dose-dependent manner, but high concentration of this antibody was associated with microhemorrhages in focal perivascular sites 62. Recently, it was reported that active immunizations with a high dose of fibrillar Aβ42 plus CFA/IFA also increased microhemorrhage in aged APP/Tg mice 22. However, only one study reported meningoencephalitis in an APP/Tg mouse model passively immunized with repeated injections of high doses of monoclonal anti-Aβ antibodies (1 mg within 16 days). Although only 1 out of 21 experimental mice were affected, the authors nonetheless suggested that an inflammatory mechanism might be triggered by antibody binding to cerebral CAA, which in turn may enhance activation of autoreactive T cells, or lead to local disruption of the BBB 85. Accordingly, in the current study we sought to investigate whether immunization with a mannan-Aβ28 conjugate might induce infiltration of T cells or increase the incidence of microhemorrhages, and CAA. While an examination of the brains did not reveal meningoencephalitis induced by the presence of T lymphocytes (data not shown), we observed an increased incidence and the severity of microhemorrhages in Tg2576 mice vaccinated with mannan-Aβ28 (Figure 4). CAA-associated microhemorrhage in aged APP/Tg mice, was ameliorated with deglycosylation of antibodies used for passive immunization 21, implicating the potential harmful effect of mannan as the trigger of adverse vascular events. Thus, we attempted to demonstrate CAA-associated microhemorrhages in vaccinated animals with anti-Aβ antibodies. We have started with examination the meningeal and cortical vascular Aβ burden, because similar to human vascular Aβ, in mice it is first detectable within leptomeninges, followed mostly by cortical, hippocampal and thalamic areas 8687. By 12 months of age, Aβ deposits in Tg2576 mice are present in the walls of leptomeningeal and cortical blood vessels, and at 15 months, the percentage load of Aβ-CAA in these areas is about 1.46% 88. As mice in our study approached 18 mo of age, the CAA score in neocortex appeared to be similar in all groups of experimental and control mice (Figure 5D). Of note, in this study we had not quantified the difference in the leptomeninges of experimental animals precisely, due to non-applicability of the standard percentage area measurements of Aβ made in parenchyma and normalized to brain region to the measurements of the meningeal location of vascular Aβ deposits.
Although the perivascular macrophages express high levels of mannose receptors 29, it is unlikely that mannan fused with Aβ28 could cross the BBB and activate these cells. Of note, infiltration of perivascular macrophages has been detected predominantly in gray matter, with the corpus callosum having very few cells, although substantial microhemorrhages in our study were detected among other areas, both in gray matter and in corpus callosum. In addition, immunization with mannan-BSA did not elevate the level of hemorrhages compared with low profiles observed in non-immunized mice (Figure 4).
Notably, titers of the anti-mannan antibodies in mannan-BSA group were higher than that in mice vaccinated with mannan-Aβ28 (Figure 1C). Although these data indicate that anti-mannan antibodies did not contribute directly to the adverse cerebral vascular events, it is possible that they may contribute to an increase in BBB permeability, thereby increasing access of anti-Aβ antibody to perivascular and parenchymal spaces in mice vaccinated with mannan-Aβ28. Importantly, we previously demonstrated that mannan-Aβ28 or Aβ28 alone did not induce microhemorrhage in the brains of wild-type mice 39.
Thus, we hypothesize that a potential cause for the incidences of microhemorrhage detected in Tg2576 mice immunized with mannan-Aβ28 may be anti-Aβ antibody binding to Aβ in cerebral vasculature. If so, one potential culprit in the microhemorrhage may be the activation of the complement cascade by antibody-Aβ immune complexes at sites of CAA 8990. Our data demonstrating that C1q and C3b are found in the cortical brain sections of mice immunized with mannan-Aβ28, but not control animals (Figure 6A) indicate that binding of antibody-Aβ to Aβ deposits in the cerebral vasculature may in fact induce microhemorrhages. Of note, we demonstrated that the level of decoration of ThS-stained vascular fibrillar Aβ with complement components C1q (Figure 6B) and C3b (data not shown) was highest in the meninges of mice immunized with mannan-Aβ28. In this group, β-amyloid deposits had altered morphology suggestive of ongoing clearance, and were heavily decorated with C1q component of complement. On the contrary, very small or practically absent C1q profiles were co-localized with substantial and unaltered Aβ load of the meninges of BSA-mannan-immunized or non-immunized groups, respectively (Figure 6B). Importantly, recently it was shown that microhemorrhages in PDAPP mice passively immunized with the 3D6 antibody, being dose-responsive, co-localized with the vascular amyloid accumulations having altered Aβ morphology 62.
It is noteworthy that the microhemorrhages triggered by anti-Aβ antibodies may play an important role in reduction of AD-like pathology, which we observed in aged Tg2576 mice vaccinated with mannan-Aβ28. This seems plausible, since only low concentrations of free anti-Aβ antibodies were detected in the sera of vaccinated mice after 11 months without further boosting with the mannan-Aβ28, and mannan-BSA did not induce microhemorrhages. Although we observed less total glial activation in the brains of mice vaccinated with mannan-Aβ28than in the brains of control animals (Figure 3), it is possible that areas affected by microhemorrhages may have higher CD45 and GFAP immunoreactivity. Future studies of the underlying mechanisms responsible for the antibody-induced microhemorrhages in mice may be useful for avoiding these potentially adverse events in AD patients receiving anti-Aβ immunotherapy.