Oral health and social and emotional well-being in a birth cohort of Aboriginal Australian young adults

1471-2458-11-656 1471-2458 Research article Oral health and social and emotional well-being in a birth cohort of Aboriginal Australian young adults JamiesonMLisalisa.jamieson@adelaide.edu.au ParadiesCYinyinp@unimelb.edu.au GunthorpeWendywendy@cattleyard.com CairneyJShereeSheree.Cairney@menzies.edu.au SayersMSusansusan.sayers@menzies.edu.au

Australian Research Center for Population Oral Health, The University of Adelaide, South Australia 5005, Australia

McCaughey Centre and Onemda VicHealth Koori Health Unit, University of Melbourne, Victoria, Australia

Menzies School of Health Research, Charles Darwin University, Darwin, Australia

BMC Public Health 1471-2458 2011 11 1 656 http://www.biomedcentral.com/1471-2458/11/656 10.1186/1471-2458-11-65621851641 20122010198201119820112011Jamieson et al; licensee BioMed Central Ltd.This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.

Abstract

Background

Social and emotional well-being is an important component of overall health. In the Indigenous Australian context, risk indicators of poor social and emotional well-being include social determinants such as poor education, employment, income and housing as well as substance use, racial discrimination and cultural knowledge. This study sought to investigate associations between oral health-related factors and social and emotional well-being in a birth cohort of young Aboriginal adults residing in the northern region of Australia's Northern Territory.

Methods

Data were collected on five validated domains of social and emotional well-being: anxiety, resilience, depression, suicide and overall mental health. Independent variables included socio-demographics, dental health behaviour, dental disease experience, oral health-related quality of life, substance use, racial discrimination and cultural knowledge.

Results

After adjusting for other covariates, poor oral health-related items were associated with each of the social and emotional well-being domains. Specifically, anxiety was associated with being female, having one or more decayed teeth and racial discrimination. Resilience was associated with being male, having a job, owning a toothbrush, having one or more filled teeth and knowing a lot about Indigenous culture; while being female, having experienced dental pain in the past year, use of alcohol, use of marijuana and racial discrimination were associated with depression. Suicide was associated with being female, having experience of untreated dental decay and racial discrimination; while being female, having experience of dental disease in one or more teeth, being dissatisfied about dental appearance and racial discrimination were associated with poor mental health.

Conclusion

The results suggest there may be value in including oral health-related initiatives when exploring the role of physical conditions on Indigenous social and emotional well-being.

Background

In the Indigenous Australian context, social and emotional well-being is a broad concept reflecting a holistic understanding of life and health. It includes mental health, as well as cultural, spiritual and social well-being 1. The concept also attempts to encompass the impact of grief and trauma through colonisation, separation from families, and loss of land and culture on Indigenous Australians 2. The social and emotional well-being of many Indigenous Australians is poor, for example, in the 2004-05 National Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Health survey, Indigenous Australians were twice as likely to report high or very high levels of psychological distress as non-Indigenous Australians. The proportion was higher among Indigenous females compared with Indigenous males 3. Indigenous Australians were also more than twice as likely to be hospitalised for intentional self-harm as non-Indigenous people 3.

A range of factors have been described as contributing to poor social and emotional well-being among Indigenous Australians. These include social determinants of health such as poor education, employment, income and housing as well as racism and level of cultural knowledge 1. While there is some evidence that infection has a direct impact on mental ill health 4, in general there is limited documentation of the role of physical conditions on Indigenous social and emotional well-being. There is even less documentation on associations with oral health-related conditions.

Oral health is an integral component of overall health and well-being. Oral diseases are not only major causes of infection and tooth loss; but may cause debilitating pain and difficulties with eating/speaking, as well as limit social interactions 567. The impact of oral disease is not confined to the mouth, with well established associations between chronic oral infections and heart 8 and lung diseases, diabetes 9, stroke 10 and pre-term low birth weight 1112.

In Australia, the oral health needs of the Indigenous population are equivalent to those in nations such as Pakistan and Uzbekistan 13. There are many reasons why preventable oral diseases are highly prevalent among this group. Financial barriers are frequently cited, together with lack of access to service providers due to social determinants of health 14. Poor oral health has a substantial impact on quality of life 15, with poor oral health-related quality of life, in turn, having a substantial impact on daily performance and general life satisfaction 16.

According to the literature, there are three oral health-related domains that have theoretically plausible associations with social and emotional well-being. These include behaviours such as organisation of appropriate dental care (associated with confidence and coping) 17 and regular toothbrushing (associated with self-esteem) 18, dental disease experience such as presence of untreated dental decay 19 and oral health-related quality of life, such as toothache causing sleep dysregulation 20 and dissatisfaction with dental appearance 21.

We set out to assess whether (i) there were associations between oral health-related outcomes and social and emotional well-being and (ii) if yes, whether associations between oral health-related outcomes and social and emotional well-being persisted after adjusting for socio-demographic, substance use, racial discrimination and cultural knowledge in a sample of Indigenous Australian young adults.

Methods

Data source

Data from Wave-3 of the Aboriginal Birth Cohort (ABC) study, a prospective, longitudinal investigation of a birth cohort of Indigenous Australians was utilised. Babies were eligible for enrolment if they were live born singletons delivered at the Royal Darwin Hospital, Northern Territory, between January 1987 and March 1990 to a mother recorded as Aboriginal 22. Within the local region at that time, 90 percent of pregnant Aboriginal mothers come to the Royal Darwin Hospital to deliver their babies 23.

Follow-ups were done at mean ages 4, 11 and most recently 18 years (Wave-3), when participants were located in more than 40 communities across the Northern Territory's Top End. The Human Research Ethics Committee of the Northern Territory Department of Health and Community Services and Menzies School of Health Research (including an Aboriginal sub-committee with absolute right of veto) granted ethics approval for each assessment phase. Study members gave informed consent before participating. Data are not openly available.

Social and emotional well-being

Participants completed 'Strong Souls'; a validated and reliable tool for screening social and emotional well-being among Indigenous young adults in the Northern Territory 24. The instrument included constructs pertaining to anxiety, resilience, depression, suicide risk and overall mental health; derived through factor analysis. Participants were asked in an interview how often they felt or experienced symptoms in the past few months, with response options including 'not much' (0), 'little bit' (1), 'fair bit' (2) and 'lots' (3). Scale scores were computed by simple item summation. A low score ('not much') indicated minimal or no issues and a high score ('fair bit' or 'lots') indicated substantial mental health issues. For resilience items, a low score indicated disagreement with the statement, indicative of lower levels of resilience and vice versa.

Anxiety comprised the following six items (high scores indicate high anxiety; possible range 0-18):

● Have you felt so sad that nothing could cheer you up?

● Have you felt so worried you start to shake?

● Have you felt so worried it was hard to breathe?

● Have you felt so worried you got really sweaty?

● Have you felt so worried you got sick in the guts?

● Have you felt so worried you got dizzy?

Resilience comprised the following nine items (high scores indicate high resilience; possible range 0-27):

● You have a strong family who help each other?

● You know lots about whitefella ways?

● You know someone who is a really good person?

● You laugh and make jokes a lot?

● You are really into something like music, cars, clothing etc?

● You are a good son or daughter to your family?

● You got an older person looking out for you?

● You got lots of friends?

● When you are upset you can usually talk to someone about it?

Depression comprised the following seven items (high scores indicate high depression; possible range 0-21):

● Have trouble sleeping?

● Get angry or wild real quick?

● Hard to focus/thinking all over the place?

● Had too many bad moods?

● Felt pretty lonely much of the time?

● Got angry or wild and stayed that way for a long time?

● Felt like giving up- no point in trying?

Suicide risk comprised the following three items (high scores indicate high suicide risk; possible range 0-9):

● Have you wished you were dead?

● Felt like hurting yourself?

● Have you felt like killing yourself?

Overall mental health was calculated by summing scores for anxiety, depression and suicide risk. Higher scores were indicative of poorer mental health, with the possible range of scores being 0 to 48. Participants identified as being at risk of poor mental health were referred to the local mental health service. An immediate consultation was arranged with mental health professionals for participants who were identified as being at risk of suicide or self harm. Aboriginal mental health workers and traditional healers were also made available to at-risk participants through their local health centre.

Oral health-related risk indicators

Participants were invited to take part in a dental examination and to complete a self-report dental questionnaire 25. Based on the literature, three domains of oral health-related outcomes were used to calculate associations with social and emotional well being: dental behaviours, dental disease experience and oral health-related quality of life.

Dental behaviour

Risk indicators relating to dental behaviours were defined as 'having seen a dentist before', 'age when last saw dentist', 'dental fear', 'toothbrush ownership', 'toothbrushing frequency' and 'age of toothbrushing onset.'

Dental disease experience

Information about clinical oral health status was collected during standardised clinical examinations conducted by two dentists who had been clinically calibrated against the gold standard examiner for the National Survey of Adult Oral Health. Examining dentists followed a standardised protocol to record levels of tooth loss, dental decay experience and periodontal disease. The DMFT (sum of decayed, missing and filled teeth in the permanent dentition) index was used to assess dental caries outcomes. All teeth present were divided into five tooth surfaces; occlusal/incisal, mesial, buccal, palatal/lingual and distal. Each dental surface was assessed and categorised using visual criteria only. Untreated dental decay (DT) was defined as 'cavitation of enamel or dentinal involvement or both being present' or 'visible caries that is contiguous with a restoration'. Filled due to decay (FT) was recorded when a tooth contained one or more permanent restorations placed to treat caries, while missing was recorded when a tooth had been extracted due to pathology (MT). Possible ranges of scores for DMFT, DT and FT are 0 to 32 for each respective measure. Dental disease experience measures were considered as percent DT > 0, percent FT > 0, percent DMFT > 0 and mean DMFT. Participants who required dental care were provided with a referral form to the nearest public health dental service provider detailing the treatment required.

The US Centres for Disease Control and Prevention and the American Academy of Periodontology definitions were used to describe moderate and severe periodontal disease; whereby moderate periodontal disease was defined as the presence of either two sites between adjacent teeth with 4 mm+ attachment loss, or at least two such sites with 5 mm+ pockets. Severe periodontal disease was classified as having at least two sites between adjacent teeth with 6 mm+ attachment loss and with at least one 5 mm+ pocket 26.

Repeat examinations to assess examiner reliability were not possible due to logistical and time constraints imposed by the study's multidisciplinary nature.

Oral health-related quality of life

Risk indicators that encapsulated oral health-related quality of life included 'frequency of dental pain', 'removal of tooth or teeth because of pain' and 'satisfaction with dental appearance'.

Covariates

Covariates included socio-demographic, substance use, racial discrimination and cultural knowledge items.

Socio-demographic

Sex, residential location, source of household income (household income itself was not collected), household size and car ownership were included. Location was dichotomised into 'regional', which included participants living in the three regional centres, and 'rural/remote' which included participants living outside the regional jurisdictions. Source of household income was defined as 'job' (i.e. employment) or 'welfare' (i.e. unemployment or various government welfare programs). Household size was assessed by the question 'How many people stayed in your house last night?' while car ownership was measured by the question 'Does someone in your house own a car?' Household size was dichotomised into response options of 'four or less' and 'five or more'.

Substance use

As part of the social and emotional well-being questionnaire, participants were asked 'how much petrol/marijuana/tobacco/alcohol do you sniff/smoke/drink' with response options including (1) 'Never or only tried it once', (2) 'Used to sniff/smoke/drink, but not any more' and (3) 'Still sniff/smoke/drink sometimes'. For purposes of this analysis the latter two response options were combined.

Discrimination

Based on items used in the National Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Health Survey 3, respondents were asked if they had ever been treated unfairly or discriminated against because they were Aboriginal, with response options dichotomised into 'not really' and 'little bit, fair bit and lots of times'.

Cultural knowledge

Participants were asked if they knew a lot about their Aboriginal culture. Responses were dichotomised into 'lots' and 'fair bit, little bit and not much'.

Data analytic approach

Univariate distributions of the five social and emotional well-being domains were determined. ANOVA was used to test the bivariate relationship between the five social and emotional well-being domains with socio-demographic, behavioural, dental disease experience, oral health impact, substance use, discrimination and cultural knowledge factors. Correlation tests between the independent variables confirmed the existence of weak associations between items in a given group (Pearson's correlation coefficient range 0.1-0.4). Based on the criteria that Pearson's correlation coefficients need to be 0.8+ to be excluded due to multicollinearity 27, no items were excluded.

To determine associations between the oral health-related factors and the five social and emotional well-being constructs, explanatory variables were entered into a series of five linear regression models, one for each of the social and emotional well-being constructs. Initial models were constructed containing all independent variables significantly associated with the outcome variables in bivariate analysis. The final regression models were constructed by removing covariates that were not statistically significant at the p < 0.05 level. Independent variables were classified into socio-demographic, dental behaviour, dental disease experience, oral health impact, substance use, discrimination and cultural knowledge items. Residual plots (plots of the standardized residuals as a function of standardized predicted values) of the models were examined to check normality assumptions, with the key properties of the residuals being lack of correlation with the independent variables, independence and homoscedasticity 28. Because these properties were observed within the dataset for the variables of interest, the use of linear regression was justified. Data were analysed using SPSS version 15.

Results

Complete data were available for 336 participants. In bivariate analyses, females had higher levels of anxiety, depression, suicide ideation and overall poor mental health (Table 1). Males, those with a job, those with a household size of 4 or less people the previous night and car owners had higher levels of resilience. Participants reporting late onset of toothbrushing had higher levels of anxiety, while those who had visited a dentist before or who owned a toothbrush had higher levels of resilience (Table 2).

Table 1

Social and emotional well-being of ABC study participants by socio-demographic factors

Anxiety

mean (95% CI)

Resilience

mean (95% CI)

Depression

mean (95% CI)

Suicide

mean (95% CI)

Mental health

mean (95% CI)

Total

2.07 (1.78-2.36)

21.64 (21.19-22.09)

4.06 (3.71-4.41)

0.52 (0.38-0.66)

6.65 (6.04-7.26)

Range

0-18

5-27

0-17

0-9

0-30

Socio-demographic

Sex

Male

1.54 (1.21-1.87)*

22.74 (22.13-23.35)*

3.34 (2.85-3.83)*

0.24 (0.14-0.34)*

5.12 (4.39-5.85)*

Female

2.53 (2.08-2.98)

20.68 (20.05-21.31)

4.69 (4.22-5.16)

0.77 (0.55-0.99)

7.99 (7.11-8.87)

Residential location

Regional

1.97 (1.38-2.56)

21.53 (20.57-22.49)

3.82 (3.08-4.56)

0.57 (0.26-0.88)

6.36 (5.11-7.61)

Rural/remote

2.10 (1.77-2.43)

21.67 (21.16-22.18)

4.13 (3.74-4.52)

0.51 (0.37-0.65)

6.74 (6.05-7.43)

Source of household income

Job

1.39 (0.68-2.10)

23.52 (22.48-24.56)*

4.11 (3.03-5.19)

0.65 (0.16-1.14)

6.15 (4.31-7.99)

Welfare

2.18 (1.87-2.49)

21.34 (20.85-21.83)

4.06 (3.69-4.43)

0.50 (0.38-0.62)

6.73 (6.10-7.36)

Household size

Four or less people

2.09 (1.48-2.70)

22.84 (21.96-23.72)*

4.31 (3.57-5.05)

0.61 (0.26-0.96)

7.01 (5.66-8.36)

Five or more people

2.09 (1.74-2.44)

21.28 (20.75-21.81)

3.94 (3.55-4.33)

0.49 (0.35-0.63)

6.51 (5.82-7.20)

Do you own a car?

2.15 (1.84-2.46)

21.43 (20.94-21.92)*

4.09 (3.72-4.46)

0.55 (0.41-0.69)

6.79 (6.14-7.44)

Yes

1.36 (0.85-1.87)

23.58 (22.42-24.74)

3.79 (2.89-4.69)

0.27 (0.02-0.52)

5.42 (4.26-6.58)

*P < 0.05

Table 2

Social and emotional well-being of ABC study participants by behavioural factors

Anxiety

mean (95% CI)

Resilience

mean (95% CI)

Depression

mean (95% CI)

Suicide

mean (95% CI)

Mental health

mean (95% CI)

Total

2.07 (1.78-2.36)

21.64 (21.19-22.09)

4.06 (3.71-4.41)

0.52 (0.38-0.66)

6.65 (6.04-7.26)

Range

0-18

5-27

0-17

0-9

0-30

Have seen dentist before?

2.06 (0.83-3.29)

19.56 (17.21-21.91)*

3.89 (2.62-5.16)

0.78 (0.27-1.29)

6.72 (4.78-8.66)

Yes

2.07 (1.78-2.36)

21.75 (21.30-22.20)

4.07 (3.72-4.42)

0.51 (0.37-0.65)

6.65 (6.02-7.28)

Age when last saw dentist

12 years or less

2.12 (1.71-2.53)

21.53 (20.92-22.14)

4.01 (3.58-4.44)

0.46 (0.30-0.62)

6.58 (5.78-7.38)

13 years or more

1.98 (1.57-2.39)

22.15 (21.46-22.84)

4.15 (3.54-4.76)

0.59 (0.35-0.83)

6.72 (5.72-7.72)

Would you feel scared about going to the dentist?

1.78 (1.43-2.13)

21.99 (21.28-22.70)

3.92 (3.35-4.49)

0.49 (0.29-0.69)

6.18 (5.32-7.04)

Little bit, fair bit, heaps

2.27 (1.84-2.70)

21.39 (20.80-21.98)

4.16 (3.73-4.59)

0.55 (0.39-0.71)

6.98 (6.16-7.80)

Toothbrush ownership

2.28 (1.65-2.91)

20.71 (19.81-21.61)*

3.91 (3.30-4.52)

0.44 (0.22-0.66)

6.63 (5.43-7.83)

Yes

1.98 (1.67-2.29)

22.00 (21.49-22.51)

4.12 (3.71-4.53)

0.56 (0.40-0.72)

6.66 (5.97-7.35)

If yes, did brush teeth yesterday?

1.69 (1.22-2.16)

21.96 (21.02-22.90)

3.62 (2.91-4.33)

0.32 (0.14-0.50)

5.63 (4.57-6.69)

Yes

2.10 (1.71-2.49)

22.10 (21.49-22.71)

4.34 (3.83-4.85)

0.65 (0.45-0.85)

7.08 (6.22-7.94)

If yes, what age when started to brush?

When had little teeth

1.66 (1.29-2.03)*

22.47 (21.82-23.12)

4.21 (3.66-4.76)

0.47 (0.31-0.63)

6.34 (5.54-7.14)

When had big teeth

2.56 (1.99-3.13)

21.45 (20.53-22.37)

4.01 (3.34-4.68)

0.71 (0.38-1.04)

7.29 (6.00-8.58)

*P < 0.05

Those with one or more teeth with untreated dental decay, those with experience of one or more decayed, missing or filled teeth, those who had experienced dental pain in the last year or who were dissatisfied with dental appearance had higher mean levels of anxiety (Table 3). Experience of filled teeth was associated with resilience. Participants with experience of decayed, missing or filled teeth or who had experienced dental pain had higher levels of depression. Experience of decayed, missing or filled teeth and dissatisfaction of dental appearance was also associated with suicide risk. Those with untreated dental disease, those with one or more teeth that was decayed, missing or filled, who had experienced dental pain and who were dissatisfied with their dental appearance had poorer overall levels of mental health.

Table 3

Social and emotional well-being of ABC study participants by dental disease experience and oral health impact factors

Anxiety

mean (95% CI)

Resilience

mean (95% CI)

Depression

mean (95% CI)

Suicide

mean (95% CI)

Mental health

mean (95% CI)

Total

2.07 (1.78-2.36)

21.64 (21.19-22.09)

4.06 (3.71-4.41)

0.52 (0.38-0.66)

6.65 (6.04-7.26)

Range

0-18

5-27

0-17

0-9

0-30

Dental disease experience

DT > 0

1.45 (1.06-1.84)*

21.36 (20.34-22.38)

3.68 (3.07-4.29)

0.41 (0.21-0.61)

5.54 (4.62-6.46)*

Yes

2.30 (1.93-2.67)

21.74 (21.25-22.23)

4.20 (3.79-4.61)

0.57 (0.41-0.73)

7.07 (6.33-7.81)

FT > 0

2.19 (1.86-2.52)

21.28 (20.75-21.81)*

3.93 (3.56-4.30)

0.50 (0.36-0.64)

6.63 (5.94-7.32)

Yes

1.58 (1.05-2.11)

23.00 (22.20-23.80)

4.58 (3.72-5.44)

0.61 (0.28-0.94)

6.77 (5.46-8.08)

DMFT > 0

1.32 (0.95-1.69)*

21.11 (19.95-22.27)

3.25 (2.68-3.82)*

0.36 (0.16-0.56)*

4.92 (4.04-5.80)*

Yes

2.29 (1.94-2.64)

21.79 (21.30-22.28)

4.30 (3.89-4.71)

0.57 (0.41-0.73)

7.16 (6.43-7.89)

Mean DT (Pearson's correlation coefficient)

0.14*

-0.02

0.05

0.15*

0.13*

Moderate or severe periodontal disease

2.09 (1.74-2.44)

21.78 (21.25-22.31)

4.07 (3.68-4.46)

0.58 (0.42-0.74)

6.74 (6.03-7.45)

Yes

2.01 (1.48-2.54)

21.25 (20.37-22.13)

4.03 (3.34-4.72)

0.37 (0.19-0.55)

6.42 (5.30-7.54)

Oral health impact

How have your teeth been since last wet?

All good, none hurting

1.62 (1.29-1.95)*

21.85 (21.24-22.46)

3.72 (3.27-4.17)*

0.43 (0.27-0.59)

5.76 (5.05-6.47)*

Some good, some hurting or none good, all hurting

2.64 (2.15-3.13)

21.36 (20.67-22.05)

4.50 (3.97-5.03)

0.65 (0.43-0.87)

7.79 (6.79-8.79)

Have you ever had a tooth removed because it hurt too much?

1.96 (1.65-2.27)

21.75 (21.24-22.26)

3.93 (3.56-4.30)

0.47 (0.33-0.61)

6.35 (5.70-7.00)*

Yes

2.52 (1.87-3.17)

21.18 (20.20-22.16)

4.61 (3.73-5.49)

0.73 (0.40-1.06)

7.87 (6.42-9.32)

Do you think your teeth look ok?

All good

1.52 (1.17-1.87)*

22.18 (21.45-22.91)

3.67 (3.06-4.28)

0.30 (0.16-0.44)*

5.48 (4.60-6.36)*

Some good or none good

2.38 (1.99-2.77)

21.34 (20.77-21.91)

4.28 (3.87-4.69)

0.65 (0.47-0.83)

7.31 (6.53-8.09)

*P < 0.05

Marijuana use was associated with depression (Table 4), while alcohol consumption demonstrated inconsistent associations; greater resilience, lower anxiety but higher depression. Experiencing discrimination was associated with anxiety, depression, suicide risk and overall poor mental health, making it the only factor related to the four negative social and emotional well-being outcomes. Participants who knew a lot about their Aboriginal culture reported higher resilience.

Table 4

Social and emotional well-being of ABC study participants by substance use, discrimination and cultural knowledge factors

Anxiety

mean (95% CI)

Resilience

mean (95% CI)

Depression

mean (95% CI)

Suicide

mean (95% CI)

Mental health

mean (95% CI)

Total

2.07 (1.78-2.36)

21.64 (21.19-22.09)

4.06 (3.71-4.41)

0.52 (0.38-0.66)

6.65 (6.04-7.26)

Range

0-18

5-27

0-17

0-9

0-30

Substance use

Tobacco

2.16 (1.63-2.69)

21.69 (20.85-22.53)

3.98 (3.25-4.71)

0.53 (0.33-0.73)

6.67 (5.49-7.85)

Yes

2.03 (1.68-2.38)

21.62 (21.07-22.17)

4.10 (3.71-4.49)

0.52 (0.36-0.68)

6.65 (5.94-7.36)

Marijuana

2.01 (1.68-2.34)

21.50 (20.93-22.07)

3.76 (3.33-4.19)*

0.49 (0.33-0.65)

6.26 (5.52-7.00)

Yes

2.16 (1.63-2.69)

21.85 (21.11-22.59)

4.53 (3.96-5.10)

0.58 (0.36-0.80)

7.27 (6.25-8.29)

Alcohol

2.37 (1.94-2.80)*

20.95 (20.32-21.58)*

3.75 (3.55-3.95)*

0.57 (0.37-0.77)

6.69 (5.87-7.51)

Yes

1.71 (1.34-2.08)

22.46 (21.83-23.09)

4.43 (4.25-4.61)

0.47 (0.29-0.65)

6.61 (5.73-7.49)

Discrimination

Treated unfairly or discriminated against because are Aboriginal?

Not really

1.66 (1.37-1.95)*

21.75 (21.20-22.30)

3.62 (3.50-3.74)*

0.40 (0.28-0.52)*

5.68 (5.01-6.35)*

Little bit, fair bit, lots

2.93 (2.32-3.54)

21.40 (20.62-22.18)

4.98 (4.69-5.27)

0.78 (0.49-1.07)

8.69 (7.53-9.85)

Cultural knowledge

Do you know a lot about your Aboriginal culture?

Not much, little bit, fair bit

1.90 (1.49-2.31)

20.49 (19.65-21.33)*

4.18 (3.59-4.77)

0.52 (-0.50-1.54)

6.61 (5.67-7.55)

Lots

2.16 (1.77-2.55)

22.27 (21.76-22.78)

4.00 (3.57-4.43)

0.53 (-0.51-1.57)

6.68 (5.92-7.44)

*P < 0.05

In multivariate modeling, anxiety was associated with being female, having one or more decayed teeth and having experienced discrimination, while being male, having a job, owning a toothbrush, having one or more filled teeth and knowing a lot about Aboriginal culture were associated with resilience (Table 5). Depression was associated with being female, having experienced dental pain in the past year, use of marijuana, use of alcohol and having felt discriminated against, while being female, having experience of untreated dental decay and discrimination were associated with suicide risk. Overall poor mental health was associated with being female, having experience of dental disease in one or more teeth, being dissatisfied about dental appearance and having experienced discrimination. In multivariate models, being female was associated with the range of social and emotional well-being outcomes as were experiences of discrimination. Other associations found in bivariate analyses were no longer common to multiple outcomes in multivariate models. Alcohol no longer acted as a protective indicator in these models but remained associated with depression.

Table 5

Multivariate models of ABC study participants with experience of poor social and emotional well-being

Anxiety

Resilience

Depression

Suicide

Mental health

B (95% CI)

Socio-demographic

Sex

Male

ref

Female

0.88 (0.32-1.44)

-1.95 (-2.81--1.09)

1.51 (0.84-2.18)

0.49 (0.25-0.74)

2.47 (1.33-3.60)

Source of household income

Job

ref

Welfare

-1.93 (-3.17-0.70)

Dental behavioural

Toothbrush ownership

ref

Yes

1.10 (0.16-2.04)

Dental disease experience

DT > 0

ref

Yes

0.78 (0.16-1.40)

FT > 0

ref

Yes

1.71 (0.66-2.77)

DMFT > 0

ref

1.38 (0.04-2.80)

Yes

Mean DT

0.034 (0.01-0.06)

Oral health impact

How have your teeth been since last wet?

All good, none hurting

ref

Some good, some hurting

or none good, all hurting

0.74 (0.08-1.40)

Do you think your teeth look ok?

All good

ref

Some good or none good

1.23 (0.01-2.47)

Substance use

Marijuana

ref

Yes

0.78 (0.07-1.49)

Alcohol

ref

Yes

0.91 (0.21-1.62)

Racial Discrimination

Treated unfairly or discriminated against because you are Aboriginal?

Not really

ref

Little bit, fair bit, lots

1.18 (0.59-1.78)

1.37 (0.67-2.07)

0.34 (0.08-0.60)

2.79 (1.59-3.99)

Cultural knowledge

Do you know a lot about your Aboriginal culture?

Not much, little bit, fair bit

ref

Lots

1.55 (0.66-2.44)

Discussion

Our findings indicate that poor oral health-related outcomes - as assessed by dental behaviours, dental disease experience and oral health-related quality of life - were associated with poor social and emotional well-being - as assessed by anxiety, resilience, depression, suicide risk and mental health - in a birth cohort of Indigenous Australian young adults, after adjustment for socio-demographics, substance use, discrimination and cultural knowledge. The results highlight the importance of including oral health-related factors when determining the broad range of factors associated with poor Indigenous social and emotional well-being, and support inclusion of oral health-related initiatives when developing interventions aimed at fostering social and emotional development among Indigenous Australian groups.

It is important to bear in mind that, being a longstanding birth cohort, the study was not designed at the outset to examine the relationship between social and emotional wellbeing and oral health. The sample size was determined at birth and not able to be increased in later stages. This study represents the largest cohort of an Australian Indigenous population that has ever been assembled, with this, in turn, being the largest study to examine social and emotional wellbeing and oral health in an Indigenous young adult population.

Before discussing implications of the findings, it is important to consider the study's limitations. We have suggested that oral health-related factors are associated with poor social and emotional well-being, but it is not possible to determine the exact causal pathway. The true relationship may be bi-directional. Although the study is longitudinal in design, oral health and social and emotional well-being items were only collected in the most recent phase. The self-report nature of many of the items may have led to an under-estimation of these factors. Although high concordance between self-report and biological measures of factors such as smoking have been reported 29, this has not been explored among a marginalised group such as Indigenous Australians, where incorrect responses may be given for any number of reasons (social desirability bias, difficulty understanding English, recall and yea-saying bias).

It is worth expanding upon each of the oral health-related components that were associated with social and emotional well-being in this study.

Dental behaviour

The only dental behaviour significantly associated with social and emotional well-being in multivariate analysis was toothbrush ownership, with ownership of a toothbrush being positively associated with resilience. In Kuwait, Honkala and colleagues 18 reported associations between recommended brushing and life- or school-satisfaction and self-esteem indicators. Factors additionally associated with resilience in our study included being male, having a job, having a filling and having more cultural knowledge. Employment and cultural identification are recognised as being among the broader determinants of health associated with social and emotional well-being 3031.

Dental disease experience

Untreated dental disease in our study was associated with anxiety. The most intuitive reason for this is because untreated dental disease can cause pain, limit function and look unsightly 19. Anxiety was also associated with being female and discrimination. In the literature it is reported that females are more likely to feel concerned about the appearance of their teeth 32. Facial attractiveness has also been found to affect social attitudes and actions, and is important in employment situations 3334.

Experience of one or more decayed, missing or filled teeth was associated with poor mental health. Most evidence in the literature suggests the opposite; that poor mental health is a risk indicator for dental disease. Severity of untreated dental disease was associated with suicide risk in this study. There is limited evidence of this relationship in the literature, although at a qualitative level, suicide has been linked to toothache in the Indigenous Australian context 35. The most common cause of toothache is severe, untreated dental disease 5.

Oral health-related quality of life

In our study, experience of dental pain in the last year was associated with depression. Depression is a complex psychological condition with many elements of pain acting as an underlying stimulus 36. It has been reported that pain and depression share underlying neurochemical mechanisms 36, with stressful life events preceeding the onset of symptoms of both chronic facial pain 37 and depression 38. It is quite possible that they may have a common underlying pathophysiology, with evidence suggesting that a larger proportion of chronic pain patients may develop depression than patients with various other chronic medical conditions 39.

Dissatisfaction with dental appearance was associated with poor overall mental health. A study of young adults in Japan found that dental malocclusion had a negative impact on self-reported mental health status 21 and, among an adult population in Karachi, perceived severity of malocclusion was significantly associated with poor psychosocial well-being 40. People suffering from problems in their tempero-mandibular joints (the joint linking the lower jaw with the rest of the skull) are more likely to suffer from mental disorders 41 and to be more severely depressed than healthy individuals 42. Indeed, depression has a high co-morbidity with chronic facial pain 43. In a qualitative study of rural-dwelling Indigenous Australian adults, it was reported that '...It affects your whole body, having toothache, your way of thinking...' and '..You see a lot of young people today with missing teeth and stuff....some feel shame about it too you know, like how it looks and everything.' 35.

Additional associations with poor social and emotional well-being among Indigenous young adults in this study warrant mention. Others have recognised that Indigenous Australian females (as with Australian females in general) have poorer social and emotional well-being than their male counterparts 3. Although reasons for this disparity are unclear, they may include Indigenous females having greater social responsibilities, less career or education options, early motherhood and general chronic disease comorbidity 3. Having a job was associated with resilience, which is intuitive given that maintaining any form of employment requires some degree of commitment and responsibility 44. Substance misuse, in the form of alcohol and marijuana, were associated with depression, supported in the literature for both Indigenous 45 and non-Indigenous 46 populations. Discrimination was associated with four of the five social and emotional well-being domains; anxiety, depression, suicide risk and overall mental ill health. This is an important finding that mirrors emerging Australian 4748495051 and international evidence that racism is an important cause of ill-health 5253; suggesting that further investigation of this topic in Australia is warranted 54. Cultural knowledge was associated with resilience, which is again supported by the literature.

It is important to consider the relevance of the findings for dental health policy and practice, specifically in delivering services to people in locations in which this study was undertaken. Indigenous young adults in the Northern Territory who own a means-tested health care card are eligible for free dental services through the public sector. Although these services are available on a reasonably regular basis, our findings indicate that many social and emotional-related factors may contribute to an individual not presenting for recommended care. Most Indigenous Australians visit a dentist because of a problem 55. Increased understanding of the associations between social and emotional well-being and oral health may help encourage policies that reflect an appreciation of this, which may, in time, result in more preventive-based dental visiting patterns.

Conclusion

In summary, our findings show that after adjustment for important socio-demographic, substance use, discrimination and cultural knowledge, poor oral health-related outcomes were associated with poor social and emotional well-being in a birth cohort of Indigenous Australian young adults. The results support the supposition that social and emotional well-being is a complex condition associated with many factors, including oral health-related outcomes. We were unable to determine true causal pathways between the oral health and social and emotional wellbeing findings, but believe the findings are still useful, particularly in providing a more comprehensive understanding of holistic health parameters. Clearly, further research is required to elucidate more clearly the causal pathways between these outcomes.

Competing interests

The authors declare that they have no competing interests.

Authors' contributions

LMJ, WG and SMS participated in data collection and manuscript preparation. YCP and SJC participated in data management and manuscript preparation. All authors were involved in revising the manuscript for important intellectual content and read and approved the final manuscript.

Acknowledgements

We thank the dedicated ABC research team who traced participants and assisted with organisation of follow-up, Andrew Lee who assisted with the dental examinations and especially the Aboriginal participants who agreed to be part of this study. The second author is supported by a University of Melbourne McKenzie Fellowship.

Australian Institute of Health and WelfareMeasuring the social and emotional wellbeing of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoplesCanberra, AIHW2009The Economic and Social Context of Indigenous HealthAltmanJThe Health of Indigenous AustraliansVictoria; Oxford University PressThomson, N20032543Australian Bureau of StatisticsNational Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Health Survey 2004-05Canberra, ABS2006No health without mental healthPrinceMPatelVSaxenaSMajMMaselkoJPhillipsMRRahmanALancet200737085987710.1016/S0140-6736(07)61238-017804063Dental cariesSelwitzRHIsmailAIPittsNBLancet2007369515910.1016/S0140-6736(07)60031-217208642Oral health and quality of lifeLockerDOral Health Prev Dent2004224725315646581Conference summary: assessing oral health outcomes--measuring health status and quality of lifeSladeGDStraussRPAtchisonKAKressinNRLockerDReisineSTCommunity Dent Health199815379791607Inflammation, periodontitis, and coronary heart diseaseKatzJMarcHPorterSRuskinJLancet2001358199811747955Periodontal disease experience in adult long-duration insulin-dependent diabeticsThorstenssonHHugosonAJ Clin Periodontol19932035235810.1111/j.1600-051X.1993.tb00372.x8501275Periodontal disease, tooth loss, and incidence of ischemic strokeJoshipuraKJHungHCRimmEBWillettWCAscherioAStroke200334475210.1161/01.STR.0000052974.79428.0C12511749Periodontal disease and adverse pregnancy outcomes: a systematic reviewXiongXBuekensPVastardisSYuSMBJOG200611313514310.1111/j.1471-0528.2005.00827.x16411989United States Department of Health and Human ServicesOral Health in America: A report of the surgeon general. Executive summaryRockville, Maryland: United States Department of Health and Human Services, National Institute of Dental and Craniofacial Research, National Institutes of Health2000World Health OrganisationGlobal oral health - country/area profile programhttp://www.whocollab.od.mah.se/countriesalphab.htmlCited 31/07/10Oral health of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander AustraliansRoberts-ThomsonKFSpencerAJJamiesonLMMed J Aust200818859259318484934Derivation and validation of a short-form oral health impact profileSladeGDCommunity Dent Oral Epidemiol19972528429010.1111/j.1600-0528.1997.tb00941.x9332805Oral Impacts on Daily Performance in Norwegian adults: validity, reliability and prevalence estimatesAstrømANHaugejordenOSkaretETrovikTAKlockKSEur J Oral Sci200511328929610.1111/j.1600-0722.2005.00225.x16048520Adolescents' sense of coherence, oral health status, and oral health-related behavioursFreireMCSheihamAHardyRCommunity Dent Oral Epidemiol20012920421210.1034/j.1600-0528.2001.290306.x11409679Do life- or school-satisfaction and self-esteem indicators explain the oral hygiene habits of schoolchildren?HonkalaSHonkalaEAl-SahliNCommunity Dent Oral Epidemiol20073533734710.1111/j.1600-0528.2006.00326.x17822482Clinical, social and psychosocial factors associated with self-rated oral health in Brazilian adolescentsPattussiMPOlintoMTHardyRSheihamACommunity Dent Oral Epidemiol20073537738610.1111/j.1600-0528.2006.00339.x17822486Psychological characteristics of Norwegian adolescents reporting no likelihood of visiting a dentist in a situation with toothacheSkaretEBergEKvaleGRaadalMInt J Paediatr Dent20071743043810.1111/j.1365-263X.2007.00869.x17935596Influence of malalignment and malocclusion on mental and physical health-consciousness in senior high school studentsInoueSTabuchiEImamuraTNoguchiMFurutaINippon Koshu Eisei Zasshi20085576877619157022An Australian Aboriginal birth cohort: a unique resource for a life course study of an Indigenous population. A study protocolSayersSMMackerrasDSinghGBucensIFlynnKReidABMC Int Health Hum Rights20033110.1186/1472-698X-3-115265112659639Northern Territory Department of Health and Community ServicesAnnual Report 1991/1992Darwin, Government Printer of the Northern Territory1992Strong Souls: the development and validation of a culturally appropriate tool for assessment of social and emotional well-being in Indigenous youthThomasACairneySGunthorpeWParadiesYSayersSAust NZ J Psychiatry201044404810.3109/00048670903393589Oral health investigations of indigenous participants in remote settings: a methods paper describing the dental component of wave III of an Australian Aboriginal birth cohort studyJamiesonLMSayersSMBMC Oral Health200882410.1186/1472-6831-8-24252729618702826Case definitions for use in population-based surveillance of periodontal diseasePageRCEkePIJ Periodontol2007781387139910.1902/jop.2007.06026417608611HurvichCMulticollinearityNew York, New York University2004MunroBHStatistical methods for health care researchPhiladelphia. Lippincott, Williams and Wilkins52005289290Tobacco-reporting validity in an epidemiological drug-use surveyFendrichMMackesy-AmitiMEJohnsonTPHubbellAWislarJSAddict Behav20053017518110.1016/j.addbeh.2004.04.00915561458Commission on Social Determinants of HealthAn Overview of Current Knowledge of the Social Determinants of Indigenous HealthWorld Health Organisation2007Commission on Social Determinants of HealthClosing the gap in a generation: Health equity through action on the social determinants of healthWorld Health Organisation2008Dental Aesthetic Index scores and perception of personal dental appearance among Turkish university studentsHamamciNBasaranGUysalEEur J Orthod20093116817310.1093/ejo/cjn08319126820Perception and significance of dental appearance: the case of missing teethOosterhavenSPWestertGPSchaubRMCommunity Dent Oral Epidemiol19891712312610.1111/j.1600-0528.1989.tb00004.x2736892At first glance: social meanings of dental appearanceEliIBar-TalYKostovetzkiIJ Public Health Dent20016115015410.1111/j.1752-7325.2001.tb03382.x11603318Using qualitative methodology to inform an Indigenous-owned oral health promotion initiative in AustraliaJamiesonLMParkerEJRichardsLHealth Promot Int200823525910.1093/heapro/dam04218056724Facial pain, depression and stress - connections and directionsKorszunAJ Oral Pathol Med20023161561910.1034/j.1600-0714.2002.00091.x12406308Psychogenic facial pain: presentation and treatmentFeinmanCJ Psychosom Res1983274031010.1016/0022-3999(83)90076-46366218The effects of stressful life events on depressionKesslerRCAnnu Rev Psychol19974819121410.1146/annurev.psych.48.1.1919046559FeinmannCThe Mouth, the Face and the MindOxford: Oxford University Press1999Assessment of psychosocial impact of dental aestheticsKhanMFidaMJ Coll Physicians Surg Pak20081855956418803894Major psychological disorders in chronic TMD patients: Implications for successful managementKinneyRKGatchelRJEllisEHoltCJ Am Dent Assoc199212349541484135Psychological factors in temporomandibular joint dysfunction: DepressionBassettDLGerkeDCGossANAust Prosthodont J1990441452096894Diagnosing depression in patients with chronic facial painKorszunAShipJAJ Am Dent Assoc1997128168016869415765Testing an integrative frameworkCooper-HakimAViswesvaranCPsychol Bull200513124125915740421Heavy cannabis use and depressive symptoms in three Aboriginal communities in Arnhem Land, Northern TerritoryLeeKSCloughARJaragbaMJConigraveKMPattonGCMed J Aust200818860560818484938Does cannabis use lead to depression and suicidal behaviours? A population-based longitudinal studyPedersenWActa Psychiatr Scand200811839540310.1111/j.1600-0447.2008.01259.x18798834'It's enough to make you sick: the impact of racism on the health of Aboriginal Australians'LarsonAGillesHowardPCoffinJAust NZ J Pub Health20073132232910.1111/j.1753-6405.2007.00079.xGallaherGZierschABaumFBentleyMPalmerCEdmondsonWWinslowLIn our own backyard: urban health inequities and Aboriginal experiences of neighbourhood life, social capital and racismAdelaide, Flinders University2009The DRUID study: Exploring mediating pathways between racism and depressive symptoms among Indigenous AustraliansParadiesYCunninghamJSoc Psychiatry Psychiatr EpidemiolRacism as a determinant of social and emotional wellbeing for Aboriginal Australian youthPriestNParadiesYGunthorpeWCairneySSayersSMed J AustExploring relationships between racism, housing and child illness in remote Aboriginal communitiesPriestNParadiesYStevenMBailieRJ Epidemiol Community HealthA systematic review of empirical research on self-reported racism and healthParadiesYInt J Epidemiol20063588890110.1093/ije/dyl05616585055Discrimination and racial disparities in health: evidence and needed researchWilliamsDRMohammedSAJ Behav Med200932204710.1007/s10865-008-9185-0282166919030981ParadiesYHarrisRAndersonIThe Impact of Racism on Indigenous Health in Australia and Aotearoa: Towards a Research AgendaCooperative Research Centre for Aboriginal Health, Darwin2008Discussion Paper Series No. 4Oral health of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander AustraliansRoberts-ThomsonKFSpencerAJJamiesonLMMed J Aust200818859259318484934

Pre-publication history

The pre-publication history for this paper can be accessed here:

http://www.biomedcentral.com/1471-2458/11/656/prepub