|Detailed overview of the main risk themes of clinical risk management in mental health care|
|Risks||Main- / subcategories||Risk description||Number spont.||Number total||Total spont.||Total overall||Mentioned organizational CRM practices (selection)|
|A||Clinical risks||General statements about clinical risks without the mention of a specific risk||1 of 11||1 of 11||1||2|
|A1||Clinical risks specific to mental health care||Clinical risks specific to mental health care, i.e. risks that occur only (or predominantly), or are typical, in mental health care||1 of 11||3 of 11||1||5||· Admission interview generally considered important|
|A1.1*||Violence / aggression||General statements about risk themes regarding violence or aggression (physical/psychological). Specific risks are listed in the sub-categories||8 of 11||10 of 11||12||42||· Aggression management training|
|· Violence risk assessment (e.g. Brøset -Checklist)|
|· Compulsory measures, sensory deprivation, seclusion|
|· Structural preventive measures|
|· When too dangerous: prison and external supervision|
|A1.1.1||Self-destructive behavior||Self-destructive behavior of a patient (e.g. suicide, suicide attempts, self-injury and self-harm: cutting.)||9 of 11||11 of 11||11||51||· Good anamnesis, pre-admission interview|
|· Clarify during admission interview and other consultations|
|· Intensive support/monitoring|
|· No-suicide contract|
|· Closing of the ward|
|· Good follow-up care and debriefing|
|A1.1.2*||Compulsory measures||Seclusion, restraint, etc. when mentioned as a risk or as a measure against a risk||4 of 11||9 of 11||4||31||· Training|
|· Standardized procedures|
|· Inform beforehand|
|· Observation and/or seclusion room|
|A1.1.3*||Next of kin, risks from the outside||Assault/threats from next of kin or from outside||1 of 11||2 of 11||1||4|
|A1.1.4*||Violence with or towards objects||Any form of violence with objects (e.g. weapons, lighters); also violence towards objects (e.g. to destroy furniture)||0||2 of 11||0||5||· No dangerous objects and infrastructure|
|· Nonflammable material in the rooms|
|A1.1.5*||Physical vs. verbal abuse||General statements specific to verbal abuse (threats) or physical abuse||0||2 of 11||0||3|
|A1.2||Treatment errors||Treatment errors / treatment risks during treatment procedure, psychotherapy||4 of 11||11 of 11||6||33||· Standard procedures for consultations|
|· Avoid one-to-one consultations|
|· Anamnesis with pro-active risk assessment|
|· Sufficient staff|
|· An ombudsman service that a patient can turn to|
|A1.2.1||Assaults by staff on patients during the therapeutic process||Assault by a staff member on a patient, especially during the therapeutic setting, that also include, for example, consensual sexual contacts or abuse of power by the therapist||2 of 11||3 of 11||2||6||· Special training|
|· Inform patients specifically about this issue|
|· Intervision (peer consulting) and supervision|
|see also A1.2|
|A1.2.2||Diagnostic errors||Establishing a diagnosis of a mental illness instead of an underlying physical illness or the misdiagnosis of psychiatric illness, which could result in incorrect treatment||1 of 11||2 of 11||2||3||· Differential diagnosis|
|· Additional tools to evaluate physical risks.|
|A1.2.3||Specific medication risks occurring mainly in psychiatry||All risks related to medication that are (mainly) psychiatric specific, especially: 1) side effects of medication. An important reason why patients do not take their medication. Risk of non-compliance. 2) accumulation, hoarding of medication (e.g. for suicide, substance abuse)||1 of 11||4 of 11||1||7||· Clarify patient’s needs|
|· Information about effects and side-effects|
|· Information on exercising and nutrition|
|· Monitor medication intake|
|A1.3||Risks associated with mental illnesses||Statements about individual illnesses (e.g. addiction, schizophrenia, acute psychosis, mania, depression, anxiety attacks, personality disorder…), that could increase certain risks||4 of 11||10 of 11||6||21||· Assessment tools|
|· Evaluate contractual capacity|
|· Intensive support|
|A1.3.1||Hospitalization against the will of the patient||Hospitalization against the will of the patient and/or against the will of next-of-kin. Also lack of insight regarding illness||3 of 11||8 of 11||3||12||· Non-voluntary hospitalization, compulsory measures|
|· Admit voluntary patients only|
|· Involuntary commitment|
|A1.3.2||Substance abuse||Drugs, smuggling of substances||1 of 11||4 of 11||1||4||· Search patients|
|· Sign addiction contract|
|A1.4||Absconding||Patient escapes from psychiatric clinic. This can happen for various reasons, e.g. hears imperative voices, suicidal tendency||3 of 11||6 of 11||4||9||· Internal transfer of patient|
|· Closing of ward|
|· Search by police|
|A2||Common clinical risks||Common clinical risks occurring in mental health care, but that are not specific, e.g. medication errors, infections. There are also grey areas such as with falls|
|A2.1||Medication risks||Common medication risks not specific to mental health care, e.g. confusing medication.||5 of 11||9 of 11||7||33|
|A2.2*||Infections and hygiene||Infections, disease transmission.||5 of 11||7 of 11||5||26||· Hygiene, hygiene standards, everything that protects against infection|
|A2.3||Falls||Falls and their consequences. Likely to be very important with withdrawal symptoms and in geronto-psychiatry||1 of 11||5 of 11||1||12|
|A2.4*||Staff risks||Lack of staff, high workload. Staff absenteeism due to illness (maybe especially high in mental health care?) Shift change, etc. → a latent condition that can increase risk of errors||1 of 11||9 of 11||2||28||· Absence management, reintegration, training|
|· Hire sufficient staff|
|· Attractive training programs|
|A2.5||Technology and equipment||Technical equipment used in the treatment of patients||2 of 11||3 of 11||2||4||· Control procedures and repair of electronic equipment|
|· Correct application and periodic maintenance|
|A2.6||High rate of internal patient transfers||Patient transfers that represent risks at the interface (change of primary caregiver, organization of transfer, etc.)||0||2 of 11||0||3|
|B*||Other risks (non-clinical)||Common, non-clinical risks (e.g. financial, structural risks, risks relating to image, etc.) e.g. fire, data protection, that represent only an indirect clinical risk||6 of 11||11 of 11||14||47|
|C*||Risks for the staff (Staff safety)||Explicit risks that mainly concern staff members||1 of 11||11 of 11||2||38||· Preventive measures (e.g. raising awareness, staff training)|
|· Active measures (e.g. de-escalation techniques, compulsory measures)|
|· Follow-up measures (e.g. debriefing, care teams)|
Description of the individual columns in Table 1:
· Risks: numbering of risk categories and sub categories (A > A1 > A1.1 etc.).
· Main category / sub category: names of the risk categories.
· Risk description: explanation of the meaning of the mentioned risk.
· Number of spontaneously mentioned risks: shows in how many of the 11 interviews the corresponding risk was spontaneously mentioned at the beginning of the interview.
· Total number: shows in how many of the 11 interviews the corresponding risk was mentioned during the interview.
· Total number of spontaneously mentioned risks: shows how often the corresponding risk was spontaneously mentioned in total at the beginning of all 11 interviews (multiple mentions in the same interview are included).
· Overall total of mentioned risks: shows how often the corresponding risk was mentioned in total during all 11 interviews (multiple mentions in the same interview are included).
· Mentioned CRM practices (selection): selection of possible measures on how to deal with the corresponding risk mentioned during the interviews.
The most important risks mentioned in more than half of the interviews or more than 20 times in total are italicized.
* Marked with an asterisk are those risks that are important to patient as well as to staff safety.
Briner and Manser
Briner and Manser BMC Health Services Research 2013 13:44 doi:10.1186/1472-6963-13-44