Table 5

Studies that estimated development rate to pupation over three or more temperatures
Study Latitude t (°C) K n r p-value
Bar-Zeev 1958 [102] 31.0461 -14.21 86.22 100 0.9975 0.001269 **
Becnel & Undeen 1992 [77] 15.87 1.13 185.46 250 0.883 0.2222
Beserra et al. 2006 [66] -7.4908 -9.91 148.46 120 0.8963 0.01464 *
Beserra et al. 2006 [66] -6.38 -7.75 187.97 120 0.9758 0.001609 **
Beserra et al. 2006 [66] -7.2256 -9.41 130.57 120 0.8663 0.02164 *
Beserra et al. 2006 [66] -7.3 -4.37 200.88 120 0.4404 0.222
Beserra et al. 2006 [66] -6.9669 -12.56 114.48 120 0.8652 0.02193 *
Gilpin & McClelland 1979 [84] -10.9491 -10.81 82.27 300 0.8875 4.80E-07 ***
Kamimura et al. 2002 [70] 24.8934 -1.62 28.64 50 0.9634 0.1225
Kamimura et al. 2002 [70] -7.2653 -9.70 122.78 50 0.9995 0.01357 *
Kamimura et al. 2002 [70] -9.2628 -9.89 122.34 50 0.9035 0.2011
Keirans & Fay 1968 [97] 18.2208 -10.79 102.18 50 0.9729 6.26E-06 ***
Lachmajer & Hien 1975 [86] 14.0583 -10.00 112.68 6300 0.9598 0.1286
Mohammed & Chadee 2011 [59] 10.6389 69.92 365.94 600 0.002094 0.9069
Ofuji 1963 [100] 32.2 -9.70 105.79 20 0.9095 0.01189 *
Padmanabha et al. 2011 [36] 10.9861 -9.09 100.97 160 0.9644 0.0004806 ***
Rueda et al. 1990 [78] 35.7721 -10.65 101.43 20 0.7966 0.01671 *
Thu et al. 1998 [76] 21.914 76.45 1124.99 100 0.0356 0.8113
Tsuda & Takagi 2001 [72] 19.5177 -10.40 153.68 50 0.6096 0.03826 *
Tun-Lin et al. 2000 [73] -10.58 -36.15 727.80 200 0.887 0.01671 *

Developmental zero (t) and linearized degree day model constant (K) are listed along with the correlation coefficient and p-value of the linear regression between temperature and development rate. Level of significance is indicated by the number of asterisks (*< 0.01; **< 0.001; ***< 0.0001).

Couret and Benedict

Couret and Benedict BMC Ecology 2014 14:3   doi:10.1186/1472-6785-14-3

Open Data