|
Responsiveness Indices for the BCTQ Symptom Severity and Functional Status Scales |
|||
| Study |
Responsiveness Indices (Measure of Clinical Change) |
||
|
|
|||
| BCTQ Functional Status Score (FS) |
BCTQ Severity of Symptoms Score (SS) |
Assessment interval |
|
|
|
|||
| Amadio et al, 1996 |
SRM = 1.26 |
SRM = 1.75 |
Before and 13.5 weeks post surgery (n = 22) |
| Atroshi et al, 1998 |
SRM = 0.94 (0.72–1.16) ES = 0.94 |
SRM = 1.7 (1.4–2.0) ES = 2.1 |
Before and 13.5 weeks post surgery (n = 102) |
| Gay et al, 2003 |
At 6 weeks after surgery SRM = 0.46; ES = 0.48 At 12 weeks after surgery SRM = 1.05; ES = 1.05 |
At 6 weeks after surgery SRM = 1.67; ES = 1.74 At 12 weeks after surgery SRM = 2.01; ES = 1.96 |
before, 6 and 12 weeks post surgery (n = 34) |
| Greenslade et al, 2004 |
SRM = 0.62 |
SRM = 1.07 |
before and 13.5 weeks post surgery (n = 57) |
| Katz et al, 1994 |
SRM = 0.96 ES = 0.86 |
SRM = 2.02 ES = 2.03 |
before and 13.5 weeks post surgery (n = 43) |
| Katz et al, 1996* |
Male WC/WCNon ES = 0.65/ES = 0.76 Female WC/WCNon ES = 1.25/ES = 1.44 |
Male WC/WCNon ES = 1.43/ES = 1.33 Female WC/WCNon ES = 1.63/ES = 2.13 |
before and 27 weeks post surgery (n = 268) |
| Levine et al, 1993 |
SRM = 0.71† greater satisfaction with the outcomes of surgery versus improvement of FS = 0.50 (p < 0.01) |
SRM = 1.13† greater satisfaction with the outcomes of surgery versus improvement of SS = 0.54 (p < 0.01) |
before and 13.5 weeks after surgery (n = 26) |
| Mondelli et al, 2002 |
ES = 1.23§ |
ES = 2.33§ |
before and 27 weeks post surgery (n = 219) |
|
Legend: WC – Workers' compensation recipients WCNon – Workers' compensation Nonrecipients * ES were not reported in paper but have been calculated based on values given in tables † responsiveness reported as ES, however calculation given is SRM (mean change/S.D change) §responsiveness assessed as differences but ES calculated from values given in paper | |||
Leite et al. BMC Musculoskeletal Disorders 2006 7:78 doi:10.1186/1471-2474-7-78 |
|||