Email updates

Keep up to date with the latest news and content from BMC Public Health and BioMed Central.

Open Access Research article

Mortality after discharge from long-term psychiatric care in Scotland, 1977 – 94: a retrospective cohort study

Cameron Stark12*, Margaret MacLeod3, David Hall4, Fiona O'Brien3 and Anthony Pelosi5

Author Affiliations

1 Highlands and Islands Health Research Institute, University of Aberdeen, The Green House, Beechwood Business Park North, Inverness, IV2 3ED, Scotland, UK

2 Highland NHS Board, Inverness, Scotland, UK

3 Information and Statistics Division, NHS Scotland, Edinburgh, Scotland, UK

4 Dumfries and Galloway Primary Care NHS Trust, Dumfries, Scotland, UK

5 Lanarkshire Primary Care NHS Trust, Coatbridge, Scotland, UK

For all author emails, please log on.

BMC Public Health 2003, 3:30  doi:10.1186/1471-2458-3-30


The electronic version of this article is the complete one and can be found online at: http://www.biomedcentral.com/1471-2458/3/30


Received:1 July 2003
Accepted:9 September 2003
Published:9 September 2003

© 2003 Stark et al; licensee BioMed Central Ltd. This is an Open Access article: verbatim copying and redistribution of this article are permitted in all media for any purpose, provided this notice is preserved along with the article's original URL.

Abstract

Background

Recent United Kingdom strategies focus on preventable suicide deaths in former psychiatric in-patients, but natural causes of death, accidents and homicide may also be important. This study was intended to find the relative importance of natural and unnatural causes of death in people discharged from long-term psychiatric care in Scotland in 1977 –1994.

Methods

People discharged alive from psychiatric hospitals in Scotland in 1977 – 94 after a stay of one year or longer were identified using routine hospital records. Computer record linkage was used to link hospital discharges to subsequent death records. Mortality was described using a person-years analysis, and compared to the general population rates.

Results

6,776 people were discharged in the time period. 1,994 people (29%) died by the end of follow-up, 732 more deaths than expected. Deaths from suicide, homicide, accident and undetermined cause were increased, but accounted for only 197 of the excess deaths. Deaths from respiratory disease were four times higher than expected, and deaths from other causes, including cardiovascular disease, were also elevated.

Conclusion

Suicide is an important cause of preventable mortality, but natural causes account for more excess deaths. Prevention activities should not focus only on unnatural causes of death.

Background

Several countries have reported high rates of suicide in people discharged from long-term psychiatric care [1]. In the United Kingdom, suicide reduction strategies in both Scotland [2] and England [3] emphasise the importance of work to reduce deaths in people who have been in-patients in psychiatric hospitals.

Suicide is a high profile event in which there is considerable public interest. The risk of psychiatric patients being themselves victims of violence has received less public attention [4]. Other countries have reported higher rates of less visible causes of death in former long-stay patients, including cardiovascular and respiratory disease [5,6]. Poor diet and high rates of cigarette smoking have been found among some groups of psychiatric patients in Scotland [7,8], but the population impact of these findings has not been investigated. We set out to identify the relative importance of suicide, homicide and other causes of death in people discharged from long-term psychiatric care in Scotland, using record linkage of NHS psychiatric hospital records and the death records of the Registrar General for Scotland.

Methods

Using the Scottish linked data set we identified people discharged from long-term hospital care in Scotland in the period 1977 – 94 who met Hassall et al's definition of a long stay patient [9], i.e. someone resident in a psychiatric hospital for a minimum of one year. Individuals with a primary diagnosis of learning disability or dementia, or those aged less than 15 years at time of discharge were excluded.

The linked data set holds all Scottish psychiatric discharges combined with the Registrar General's death records [10]. The file covered the years 1977 – 94 and contained over 2 million records, representing in excess of 900,000 individuals. Records for each individual are held together allowing follow-up of in-patient health care and subsequent mortality over a 17 year period. This data set was used to identify long stay patients, as defined above, discharged alive from Scottish Psychiatric Hospitals in 1977 – 94.

A person years analysis of mortality was carried out using the person years programme [11]. We compared deaths in the long stay cohort to those in the Scottish population for all causes; suicide (ICD 9 950 – 959); undetermined deaths (ICD 9 980 – 989); homicide (960 – 969); external causes (E800 – E949, E970 – E979, E990 – E994); infectious and parasitic diseases (10 – 139); all neoplasms (140 – 239); endocrine (240 – 279); mental disorders (290 – 292); nervous system (320 – 326); circulatory system (390 – 459); respiratory system (460 – 519); digestive system (520 – 579) and genitourinary system (580 – 629). Deaths recorded as suicide and those recorded as undetermined were grouped together for further analyses. Expected numbers were calculated from general population rates adjusting for gender, age (5-year age bands), and calendar-specific discharge periods (5-year groups).

Results

The cohort

6,776 people met the criteria for entry into the cohort. The demographic and diagnostic characteristics of the group are shown in Table 1 by period of discharge. Schizophrenia was the commonest single diagnosis in each period. In all, there were 53,710 person years of follow-up. The commonest diagnoses included in the "Other" category were alcohol dependence, paranoid states and alcohol-related psychoses.

Table 1. Demographic Characteristics of Patients by Discharge Cohort, Scotland 1977 – 94

Deaths

1,994 of the cohort (29%) died during the follow up period, compared to 1262 deaths that would have been expected from general population rates, an excess of 732 deaths. The odds ratio for all cause mortality was 1.58 (CI 1.51 – 1.66). Table 2 shows deaths by cause. 232 deaths were accounted for by suicide, undetermined causes, homicide and accidents. Taking into account the number of deaths that would have been expected in these categories, 197 of the excess deaths were accounted for by these unnatural causes. The majority of the excess deaths had natural causes, particularly circulatory and respiratory disease.

Table 2. Deaths by Cause, Both Sexes, 1977 – 94

Discussion

This paper provides the first information on deaths among people discharged from long-term psychiatric care in Scotland. Previous literature has either been from outside the United Kingdom, or relates to specific discharge programmes [12] or diagnoses [13]. This cohort was discharged as part of routine care, and therefore allows an insight into deaths among a general psychiatric population. The study followed the convention of dividing deaths into natural and unnatural [5]. In keeping with the work of Trieman et al [12] and Harris and Barraclough [5] all cause mortality was elevated, as were deaths from both natural and unnatural causes.

Death by suicide, and from undetermined cause, occurred more frequently than would have been expected in the general population. The elevated risk of suicide, around 13 times higher than expected, was higher than Harris and Barraclough's [1] meta-analysis result for discharged patients (SMR 693), but similar to their community care result (SMR 1280, CI 1111-1608). This may be related to our exclusion of anyone discharged with a length of stay under one year, hence increasing the proportion of people in the Scottish cohort who suffer from severe illness.

Homicide deaths were elevated, with five deaths occurring, compared to the one death that would have been expected. Hiroeh et al [4] reported similar findings from a Case Register based study in Denmark, with a six-fold elevation in homicide rates in people who had ever been admitted to a psychiatric hospital. They concluded that the public and the media, traditionally concerned with potential risk from mental health service users, should be aware of the vulnerability of service users to violence directed against them. Our findings suggest that these observations are as relevant in the UK as in Denmark.

Deaths from natural causes were also elevated in this Scottish cohort. Circulatory disorders accounted for the greatest number of deaths, and were around 50% higher than expected. Respiratory disease was responsible for the next greatest number of excess deaths, and was four times higher than expected. Harris and Barraclough [5] reported increased rates of circulatory and respiratory disease in their systematic review, when looking at psychiatric patients from all treatment settings. When looking at former in-patients, they were able to identify fewer studies, but found that death rates from infectious and respiratory disease were elevated. Sohlman and Lehtinen [6] reported elevated death rates from cardiovascular disease in a recent Finish ex-inpatient discharge cohort. The Scottish findings are in line with these previous findings, and allow Harris and Barraclough's findings on the general psychiatric population to be extended to those discharged from long-term care.

The reasons for these marked increases in non-violent forms of death are not clear. More disease may occur in this population, for example because of greater exposure to risk factors such as smoking, excess alcohol use or poor diet. Anti-psychotic drug use may also account for some cardiovascular deaths [14,15]. It is also possible that access to health care may be more limited for this group, or that they might be treated differently from people who have not had a mental illness. In relation to exposure to risk factors in Scotland, Kelly and McCreadie [16] have reported smoking rates in people with schizophrenia of twice that of the general population. They point out [8] that smoking disadvantages their patients financially as well as physically. Again in people with schizophrenia, Brown et al [13] concluded that cigarette smoking was likely to explain much of the excess risk in people in the community. Poor diet and lack of exercise are also likely to be important [7,17].

Brown et al [13] concluded that improved recognition of disease, better treatment and improved compliance might have reduced the number of deaths in the cohort they described. There may, however, be barriers to people with mental illness accessing good quality care [18]. In the United States, Druss et al [19] reported that older people with mental illnesses did not always receive high quality care after a myocardial infarction. Schizophrenia and major affective disorders appeared initially to be associated with increased mortality after an infarct, but these differences disappeared after adjusting for indicators of quality of care. Similarly, in Western Australia there was little difference in cancer incidence rates in people on a mental health service register compared to the general population, but a substantial increase in mortality [20]. The authors attributed this finding to a higher case fatality rate, again raising the possibility of different treatment, or reduced compliance, in the group of people who had been in contact with mental health services.

Using record linkage to establish a large cohort allowed examination of other causes of death. This work is limited by the use of only routinely collected information. We had no opportunity to verify diagnoses in hospital, or of causes of death after discharge. There is a trade off between the ability to examine an entire national cohort and the loss of qualitative information [21]. The main routine data set used, the SMR4 (now the SMR04) has inaccuracies [22], although these have reduced in recent years. The information we used from the SMR4 scheme, apart from patient identifiers, was limited to admission and discharge dates and diagnosis and so there should be limited opportunities for biases to arise from the use of this dataset. Our method did not allow us to identify any deaths occurring outside Scotland, and it is therefore possible that the rates underestimate the risk of death. We did not examine differential death rates by diagnosis, and this should be explored in future research.

Conclusions

We conclude that death rates in people discharged from long-term psychiatric care in Scotland are substantially higher than would be expected from general population rates. Suicide remains an important cause of death in this group of people, as do accidents and violence. More potential deaths could be prevented by successfully reducing the number of deaths from physical ill-health, however, than from suicide reduction measures. Services should review the support offered to patients after discharge and consider pursuing health promotion measures aimed at reducing smoking and improving diet. Researchers should seek to identify any systematic differences in the quality of care offered to people with mental health problems, compared to treatment accessed by the general population, and to examine differential death rates by diagnostic group. Higher death rates in people with mental health problems have been recognised in the UK for 160 years [23]. In the drive to reduce social inequalities, UK agencies need to target work at the health inequalities experienced by people who have used psychiatric services.

Competing interests

Cameron Stark is a Public Health Adviser to the National Schizophrenia Fellowship (Scotland)

Authors' contributions

Cameron Stark had the original idea for the study, contributed to the design and wrote the paper. Margaret MacLeod and Fiona O'Brien analysed the data. David Hall contributed to the design, advised on interpretation of results, and helped draft the paper. Anthony Pelosi contributed to the design and advised on interpretation of results. Fiona O'Brien died during the preparation of this paper.

Acknowledgements

NHS Highland and the Information and Statistics Division of NHS Scotland supported the work. Sandra Ferguson provided computing assistance. Professor David Godden of the Highlands and Islands Health Research Institute and Dr David Gunnell of the University of Bristol provided helpful comments on the paper.

References

  1. Harris EC, Barraclough B: Suicide as an outcome for mental disorders. A meta-analysis.

    British Journal of Psychiatry 1997, 170:205-228. PubMed Abstract | Publisher Full Text OpenURL

  2. Scottish Executive:

    National Framework for the Prevention of Suicide and Deliberate Self-Harm in Scotland: Consultation Document. Edinburgh. 2002. OpenURL

  3. Department of Health:

    National Suicide Prevention Strategy. London. 2002. OpenURL

  4. Hiroeh U, Appleby L, Mortensen PB, Dunn G: Death by homicide, suicide and other unnatural causes in people with mental illness: a population-based study.

    Lancet 2001, 358:2110-2112. PubMed Abstract | Publisher Full Text OpenURL

  5. Harris EC, Barraclough B: Excess mortality of mental disorder.

    British Journal of Psychiatry 1998, 173:11-53. PubMed Abstract | Publisher Full Text OpenURL

  6. Sohlman B, Lehtinen V: Mortality among discharged psychiatric patients in Finland.

    Acta Psychiatrica Scandinavica 1999, 99:102-109. PubMed Abstract | Publisher Full Text OpenURL

  7. McCreadie RG, MacDonald E, Blacklock C, Tilak-Singh D, Wiles D, Halliday J, Paterson J: Dietary intake of schizophrenic patients in Nithsdale, Scotland: case-control study.

    BMJ 1998, 317:784-785. PubMed Abstract | Publisher Full Text | PubMed Central Full Text OpenURL

  8. McCreadie RG, Kelly C: Patients with schizophrenia who smoke. Private disaster, public resource.

    British Journal of Psychiatry 2000, 176:109. Publisher Full Text OpenURL

  9. Hassall C, Spencer AM, Cross KW: Some changes in the composition of a mental hospital population.

    British Journal of Psychiatry 1965, 111:420-428. OpenURL

  10. Kendrick S, Clarke J: The Scottish record linkage system.

    Health Bulletin 1993, 51:72-79. PubMed Abstract | Publisher Full Text OpenURL

  11. Coleman M, Douglas A, Hermon C, Peto J: Cohort study analysis with a FORTRAN computer program.

    International Journal of Epidemiology 1986, 15:134-137. PubMed Abstract | Publisher Full Text OpenURL

  12. Trieman N, Leff J, Glover G: Outcome of long stay psychiatric patients resettled in the community: prospective cohort study.

    BMJ 1999, 319:13-6. PubMed Abstract | Publisher Full Text | PubMed Central Full Text OpenURL

  13. Brown S, Inskip H, Barraclough B: Causes of the excess mortality of schizophrenia.

    British Journal of Psychiatry 2000, 177:212-217. PubMed Abstract | Publisher Full Text OpenURL

  14. Zarate CA: Sudden cardiac death and antipsychotic drugs: Do we know enough?

    Archives of General Psychiatry 2001, 58:1168-1171. PubMed Abstract | Publisher Full Text OpenURL

  15. Hennessy S, Bilker WB, Knauss JS, Margolis DJ, Kimmel SE, Reynolds RF, Glasser DB, Morrison MF, Strom BL: Cardiac arrest and ventricular arrhythmia in patients taking antipsychotic drugs: cohort study using administrative data.

    BMJ 2002, 325:1070-2. PubMed Abstract | Publisher Full Text | PubMed Central Full Text OpenURL

  16. Kelly C, McCreadie RG: Smoking habits, current symptoms, and premorbid characteristics of schizophrenic patients in Nithsdale, Scotland.

    American Journal of Psychiatry 1999, 156:1751-1757. PubMed Abstract | Publisher Full Text OpenURL

  17. Brown S, Birtwhistle J, Roe L, Thompson C: The unhealthy lifestyle of people with schizophrenia.

    Psychological Medicine 1999, 29:697-701. PubMed Abstract | Publisher Full Text OpenURL

  18. Goldman LS: Comorbid medical illness in psychiatric patients.

    Current Psychiatry Reports 2000, 2:256-263. PubMed Abstract | Publisher Full Text OpenURL

  19. Druss BG, Bradford WD, Rosenheck RA, Thompson C: Quality of medical care and excess mortality in older patients with mental disorders.

    Archives of General Psychiatry 2001, 58:565-572. PubMed Abstract | Publisher Full Text OpenURL

  20. Lawrence D, Holman CDJ, Jablensky AV, Threlfall TJ, Fuller SA: Excess cancer mortality in Western Australian psychiatric patients due to higher case fatality rates.

    Acta Psychiatrica Scandinavica 2000, 101:382-388. PubMed Abstract | Publisher Full Text OpenURL

  21. Hall DJ, O'Brien F, Stark C, Pelosi A, Smith H: Thirteen-year follow-up of deliberate self-harm, using linked data.

    British Journal of Psychiatry 1998, 172:239-242. PubMed Abstract | Publisher Full Text OpenURL

  22. McGonigal G, McQuade C, Thomas B: Accuracy and completeness of Scottish mental hospital in-patient data.

    Health Bulletin 1992, 50:309-314. PubMed Abstract | Publisher Full Text OpenURL

  23. Singer RB: The first mortality follow-up study: the 1841 Report of William Farr (physician) on the mortality of lunatics.

    Journal of Insurance Medicine 2001, 33:294-309. OpenURL

Pre-publication history

The pre-publication history for this paper can be accessed here:

http://www.biomedcentral.com/1471-2458/3/30/prepub