Unexpectedly high burden of rotavirus gastroenteritis in very young infants

Abstract

Background

The highest incidence of rotavirus gastroenteritis has generally been reported in children 6-24 months of age. Young infants are thought to be partially protected by maternal antibodies acquired transplacentally or via breast milk. The purpose of our study was to assess the age distribution of children with confirmed community-acquired rotavirus gastroenteritis presenting to an urban referral hospital.

Methods

Children presenting to The Children's Hospital of Philadelphia with acute gastroenteritis have been monitored for the presence of rotavirus antigen in the stool by ELISA (followed by genotyping if ELISA-positive) since the 1994-95 epidemic season.

Results

Over the last 12 rotavirus seasons prior to the introduction of the pentavalent rotavirus vaccine in 2006, stool specimens from 1646 patients tested positive for community-acquired rotavirus infection. Gender or age was not recorded in 6 and 5 cases, respectively. Overall, 58% of the cases occurred in boys. G1 was the predominant VP7 serotype, accounting for 72% of cases. The median (IQR) age was 11 (5-21) months. A total of 790 (48%) cases occurred in children outside the commonly quoted peak age range, with 27% in infants <6 months of age and 21% in children >24 months of age. A total of 220 (13%) cases occurred during the first 3 months of life, and the highest number of episodes per month of age [97 (6%)] was observed during the second month of life.

Conclusions

The incidence of community-acquired rotavirus gastroenteritis monitored over 12 seasons in the prevaccine era at a major university hospital was nearly constant for each month of age during the first year of life, revealing an unexpectedly high incidence of symptomatic rotavirus disease in infants <3 months old. A sizeable fraction of cases occurred in children too young to have been vaccinated according to current recommendations.

Background

In the absence of a safe and effective vaccine (1-3), rotavirus has consistently been the leading cause of dehydrating gastroenteritis in infants and young children around the world (4-20). Virtually all children are infected at least once within the first 5 years of life, with the peak incidence widely quoted as occurring between 6 and 24 months of age (5, 7, 11, 13, 14, 16, 20-23). For the first few months of life, infants are thought to be partially protected by maternal antibodies acquired transplacentally or through breast feeding (24-26). The Advisory Committee on Immunization Practices currently recommends the initiation of the rotavirus vaccine series at 2 months of age, although the first dose can be given as early as age 6 weeks (27, 28). If infants during the first few months of life are at greater risk for symptomatic rotavirus infection than has been generally appreciated, routine immunization schedules might be reconsidered in order to extend the benefits of rotavirus vaccine to these vulnerable infants. Of course, the safety, effectiveness, and feasibility of immunizing neonates would have to be established. We examined the age distribution of children presenting to The Children's Hospital of Philadelphia (CHOP) with community-acquired rotavirus gastroenteritis prior to the recent introduction of the new rotavirus vaccines to assess the burden of rotavirus infection serious enough to motivate hospital visits in neonates and young infants.

Methods

The surveillance protocol was approved by the institutional review board at CHOP (1, 29, 30). Informed consent from legal guardians was not required to procure and process stool specimens already obtained from children with acute gastroenteritis as part of standard clinical practice. Based on prior experience, the rotavirus epidemic season in Philadelphia was defined as the seven-month period from December 1 through June 30 of the following year (1, 29, 31). For 14 consecutive rotavirus seasons (1994-95 to 2007-08), all patients (regardless of age) presenting to CHOP with acute gastroenteritis and having an adequate stool sample were tested by a commercial qualitative enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) for rotavirus antigen (Premier Rotaclone, Meridian Bioscience, Cincinnati, OH).

For the first 5 rotavirus seasons studied (1994-95 to 1998-99), a subset of ELISA-positive clinical samples were analyzed at the Centers for Disease Control (CDC) as part of a national surveillance program. Viruses of identical electropherotype to our samples serotyped at the CDC were considered the same as the reference type (32). Beginning with the 1999-2000 season, ELISA-positive specimens were submitted to Merck Research Laboratories (MRL) for genotyping by reverse transcriptase-polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR) if the quantity of the stool sample permitted. For the MRL analysis, a 365-bp RT-PCR product targeting the VP7 gene was amplified from isolated RNA and subsequently sequenced (33). Designation of G-type was based on nucleic acid homology in comparison with a database of sequences of known serotypes.

For the present analysis, only community-acquired cases during the last 12 rotavirus seasons prior to the introduction of the pentavalent rotavirus vaccine (RV5; RotaTeq, Merck, Whitehouse Station, NJ, USA) in 2006 were analyzed. A monovalent rotavirus vaccine (RV1; Rotarix, GlaxoSmithKline Biologicals, Rixensart, Belgium) was approved in April 2008. A tetravalent vaccine (Rotashield, Wyeth, Collegeville, PA, USA) had been temporarily available in the United States in 1998-99 before being withdrawn from the market because of the risk of intussusception. Families seeking care at CHOP resided for the most part in Philadelphia or its immediately surrounding suburbs (34). Hospital-acquired infections, defined as developing >48 hours after admission or <48 hours after discharge, were excluded. Nosocomial infections had constituted ~20% of the total number of rotavirus cases diagnosed at CHOP in the pre-RV5 era (30). For each season and for all twelve seasons combined, the median (interquartile range [IQR]) age in months was calculated for children presenting to CHOP with community-acquired rotavirus gastroenteritis.

Results

A total of 1646 unique community-acquired cases of rotavirus gastroenteritis were identified during 12 seasons from 1994-95 to 2005-06 (Table 1). Gender or age was not recorded in 6 and 5 cases, respectively. There were a higher percentage of boys than girls in each season, and overall there were 58% (n = 947) male cases and 42% (n = 693) female cases in the combined 12 monitored seasons (excluding the 6 cases where the gender was not recorded). The race for the majority of children when known was non-white. The predominant serotype was G1 (ranging from 41%-97%); however, the 1994-95 season had a high percentage of G3 cases (93%), the 1995-96 and 1999-2000 seasons had a high percentage of G9 cases (52% and 41%, respectively,) and the 2005-2006 season had a high percentage of G2 cases (39%).

Table 1 Demographic characteristics of the 1646 community-acquired cases of rotavirus gastroenteritis presenting to CHOP in the pre-vaccine era^◊ between the 1994-95 and 2005-06 epidemic seasons

The median [IQR] age for the 1641 evaluable cases over the combined 12 rotavirus epidemic seasons prior to the availability of RV5 was 11 [5–21] months, with a full range of 0-240 months (Figure 1). Overall, 48% of children fell outside the commonly quoted peak age range of 6-24 months, with 27% of cases occurring in infants <6 months of age and 21% of cases occurring in children >24 months of age (Figure 2). A total of 220 (13%) cases occurred during the first 3 months of life, and the highest number of episodes per month of age [97 (6%)] were observed during the second month of life. In contrast to the prevaccine era, the median age of children presenting to CHOP with community-acquired rotavirus gastroenteritis during the 2007-08 season was 20 months and during the 2008-09 season was 23.5 months.

Figure 1

Age distribution of the 1641 evaluable community-acquired rotavirus cases presenting to CHOP during the last 12 rotavirus epidemic seasons (1994-05 through 2005-06) prior to introduction of the new rotavirus vaccines. A histogram shows the frequency of community-acquired rotavirus cases presenting to CHOP by age for the entire 12-year time period under study. Mean age = 18.1 months; standard deviation = 25.1 months; minimum age = 0 months; Q1 = 5 months; median age = 11 months; Q3 = 21 months; maximum age = 240 months; IQR = 16 months. Age was not recorded for 5 of the 1646 children with community-acquired rotavirus gastroenteritis presenting to CHOP during this period, who were therefore excluded from the analysis.

Figure 2

A pie chart depicting the incidence of community-acquired rotavirus cases presenting to CHOP during the last 12 rotavirus epidemic seasons (1994-05 through 2005-06) prior to introduction of the new rotavirus vaccines. Each slice is identified by age grouping, number of cases in the specified age range, and percentage of cases in the specified age range.

The serotype distribution by age group is displayed in Table 2. Despite some fluctuation in the predominant circulating serotype in the community, the age distribution was generally similar for each of the 12 seasons. However, for the two most common VP7 types, G1 cases occurred slightly less often in children <6 months of age (63%) than in older children (>70%), whereas G2 cases occurred twice as frequently in children during the first 6 months of life (19%) compared to children during the second 6 months of life (9%). Although the number of cases was relatively small, G9 rotaviruses were also disproportionately represented in children under the age of 6 months (11%) versus older children (<7%).

Table 2 Serotype of community-acquired rotavirus cases presenting to CHOP during the 6 rotavirus epidemic seasons (1999-2000 through 2005-06)^§ prior to introduction of the new rotavirus vaccines^◊ by age

Discussion

Although rotavirus accounts for an estimated half-million deaths each year in the developing world (17), the public health burden of rotavirus gastroenteritis in industrialized nations is largely measured in infant morbidity, healthcare costs, missed daycare, and loss of time from work for parents/guardians (6, 9, 11, 13, 15, 16, 19, 23, 35, 36). The rotavirus epidemic season in the United States typically begins in the autumn in the Southwest and spreads across the country ending in the spring of the following calendar year in the Northeast (31). Rotavirus infections typically peak in Philadelphia during March and April (1, 29, 35).

The general consensus dating back to the seminal report of a "reovirus-like agent" as the major cause of "winter" gastroenteritis in hospitalized infants and young children has been that symptomatic rotavirus infections predominantly afflict children between 6 and 24 months of age (14). Despite published data to the contrary (4, 9, 10, 15, 37, 38), respected textbooks of infectious diseases (5, 20) continue to propagate the dogma that rotavirus gastroenteritis is largely a disease of children older than 6 months of age through their second birthday. Assuming that the age distribution of the population served by CHOP is not skewed, we found that the monthly incidence of community-acquired rotavirus cases during the 12 years prior to licensing of RV5 was consistently high from birth to 12 months of age, followed by a marked and sustained decline in children older than 1 year. By compiling incidence data for individual months of age rather than for clusters, a high rotavirus attack rate was evident during the first 3 months of life. The highest number of episodes per month of age was seen among children in their second month of life. The surprising frequency of neonatal cases demonstrates that a non-trivial number of newborns might not be adequately protected by maternal antibodies (25, 26). The clear excess of rotavirus disease during the first versus second year of age in our experience also conflicts with several studies where more rotavirus disease was reported in the second year rather than the first year of life (9, 11, 12, 23).

Some differences between our data and earlier reports are more apparent than real. For example, the benchmark article by Kapikian et al. identified "reovirus" in stool specimens by electron microscopy from 60 of 143 tested children hospitalized with "winter" gastroenteritis, a not inconsequential 10 (17%) of whom were <6 months of age (14). Although the proportion of cases with "reovirus" identified in stool samples was threefold higher in children 6-12 months old [25 of the 39 children tested (64%)] than in younger infants [10 of the 48 children tested (21%)] hospitalized in the winter for acute gastroenteritis, these data are often misconstrued as establishing that symptomatic rotavirus infection before age 6 months is rare in an absolute sense. Other seeming inconsistencies between our findings and previously published data might be explained by selection and ascertainment biases, racial and socioeconomic factors, variations in the circulating serotypes, and/or geographical differences. As an illustration, for rotavirus gastroenteritis in the United States, hospitalization of black infants tends to occur on average at a younger age than hospitalization of white infants (7, 16). In addition, G2 rotavirus infections at CHOP occurred twice as frequently in children <6 months of age than in children 6-12 months of age. To further complicate direct comparisons of our results with prior studies indicating that infection with rotavirus in young infants requiring a healthcare intervention is not uncommon (4, 37, 38), some publications do not clearly distinguish nosocomial from community-acquired acquisition.

The methodological limitations of our analysis should be acknowledged. We did not directly assess the population incidence of severe rotavirus gastroenteritis. Instead, we used the number of children presenting to CHOP with acute gastroenteritis associated with a rotavirus-positive ELISA as our denominator. The index of suspicion for rotavirus infection might be influenced by the age of the child, and stool specimens may be more or less likely to be obtained from diapered babies than older children. The age distribution for community-acquired cases presenting to the hospital may be skewed toward younger age groups relative to the overall distribution in the community because infants may be more compromised by gastroenteritis than older children and/or parents may be more likely to seek medical attention for younger than for older children. Even though our approach may be confounded by selection bias, the sample is likely representative of the general population of children sick enough to necessitate a hospital visit for community-acquired rotavirus infection. While admittedly not definitive, these results indicate a need to re-examine the conventional wisdom and its implications for clinical practice as we move forward in the rotavirus vaccine era.

Conclusions

The peak incidence of serious rotavirus infections is still generally quoted as occurring in children after 6 months of age and extending out to 24 months of age (5, 20). Although true in a cumulative sense, the monthly incidence of community-acquired cases seen at our hospital was comparable for both halves of the first year of life, and then dramatically dropped off. Based on 12 rotavirus seasons monitored at CHOP prior to the introduction of the recently licensed vaccines, we found a large fraction (48%) of cases outside the putative peak age range of 6-24 months. At CHOP from 1994-95 to 2005-06, the highest monthly incidence of rotavirus gastroenteritis was observed during the second month of life, by which time levels of maternal antibody against rotavirus may have substantially waned in many infants (25). Widespread uptake of an effective rotavirus vaccine could reduce maternal antibody levels by inducing herd immunity and reducing adult infections. On the other hand, herd immunity might serve to prevent infection in yet-to-be-vaccinated infants. Rotavirus vaccines are usually given to infants at ~2 months of age; even 1 dose of either the monovalent (RV1) or pentavalent (RV5) vaccine likely affords some protection against severe disease within 2 weeks of administration bridging the gap until the next dose. Subsequent to the introduction of the new rotavirus vaccines, the relative frequencies of cases in children both younger than 6 months and older than 2 years have increased at CHOP (1). Infants in the first few months of life may remain vulnerable to serious rotavirus infections and constitute a sizeable fraction of the cases seen at CHOP. Our findings should prompt a possible rethinking of the optimal rotavirus immunization schedule in order to safely and effectively balance the heretofore underappreciated susceptibility of newborns with concerns about suboptimal vaccine responses in the presence of maternal antibodies (28, 39-46).