Table 1

Summary of including studies (Insufficient Samples Excluded in test result)

study

year

reference standard

test result

patients (number)

QUADAS score


TP

FP

FN

TN


Walker et al.[33]

1998

his

91

0

0

19

110

13

Kanchanabat et al.[11]

2000

his/imag and clin

8

8

0

26

42

10

Pisano et al.[12]

2001

his/imag and clin

59

18

17

183

277

11

Lumachi et al.[34]

1999

his

55

0

2

5

62

10

Farshid et al.[35]

2008

his/imag and clin

91

120

2

880

1093

11

Dennison et al.[36]

2003

his/imag and clin

95

0

10

38

143

10

Gent et al.[37]

1986

his

39

7

1

109

156

13

Wanebo et al.[38]

1983

his

123

8

1

102

234

13

Apesteguia et al.[39]

1997

his/imag and clin

2

2

0

107

111

11

Manheimer et al.[40]

1977

his

79

2

11

35

127

11

Janet et al.[41]

2010

his/imag and clin

11

0

4

135

150

9

Drew et al.[42]

1999

his/imag and clin

102

4

27

130

263

8

Masood et al.[43]

1991

his

17

0

3

71

91

8

Ishikawa et al.[44]

2007

his

138

4

4

178

324

12

Harvey et al.[45]

1996

his/imag and clin

14

37

13

32

96

8

Leifland et al.[46]

2003

his

353

11

52

27

443

11

Okamoto et al.[47]

1998

his/imag and clin

5

1

1

125

132

11

Rubin et al.[48]

1997

his/imag and clin

34

4

0

27

65

10

Sauer et al.[32]

2003

his/imag and clin

360

21

47

321

749

11

Li et al.[49]

2008

his

129

1

22

108

260

9

Wang et al.[50]

2010

his

110

2

7

55

174

13

Yang et al.[51]

2010

his

79

0

4

259

342

11

Liu et al.[52]

2000

his

205

1

12

194

412

10

Zhao et al.[53]

2009

his

218

10

6

241

475

11

Zhan et al.[54]

2007

his

32

2

0

44

78

9

Gao et al.[55]

2005

his

169

0

27

85

281

11

Lu et al.[56]

2010

his

102

0

33

48

183

10

Liu et al.[57]

2010

his

5

1

1

125

132

11

Zhang et al.[58]

2008

his

39

6

4

53

102

11

Zhang et al.[59]

2006

his

21

2

3

31

57

9

Tang et al.[60]

1987

his

144

2

13

144

303

11

Wang et al.[61]

1995

his

25

0

2

22

49

10

Ma et al.[62]

2010

his

56

0

2

99

157

8

Wang et al.[63]

2010

his

96

12

4

498

610

8

Wang et al.[64]

1981

his

442

43

60

479

1024

10

Wei et al.[65]

2007

his

91

4

2

78

175

12

Tao et al.[66]

2004

his

655

5

14

2027

2701

12

Wang et al.[67]

2005

his

99

5

0

207

311

11

Chen et al.[68]

2010

his

66

1

9

176

252

8

Zeng et al.[69]

1999

his

94

1

2

66

163

11

Jia et al.[70]

1986

his

49

0

1

50

100

9

Ma et al.[71]

2010

his

68

0

4

291

363

10

Huang et al.[72]

2003

his

305

31

54

436

826

11

Zhang et al.[73]

1996

his

21

1

2

40

64

9

Yu et al.[74]

2006

his

1620

116

33

359

2128

11

Jiang et al.[75]

2008

his

66

1

9

176

252

11


His: histopathology; imag and clin:imaging and clinical follow-up; TP:true positive; FP: false positive; FN:false negative; TN: true negative.

Yu et al. BMC Cancer 2012 12:41   doi:10.1186/1471-2407-12-41

Open Data