The ancient evolutionary origins of Scleractinia revealed by azooxanthellate corals
1 Institute of Paleobiology, Polish Academy of Sciences, Twarda 51/55, PL-00-818 Warsaw, Poland
2 ARC Centre of Excellence for Coral Reef Studies and Coral Genomics Group, James Cook University, Townsville, QLD 4811, Australia
3 Department of Invertebrate Zoology, National Museum of Natural History, Smithsonian Institution, Washington, D.C., 20560 USA
4 Department of Chemistry, Laboratory of Electrochemistry, University of Warsaw, Pasteura 1, PL-02-093 Warsaw, Poland
5 Muséum National d'Histoire Naturelle, Laboratoire de Mineralogie et Cosmochimie du Museum, LMCM UMR 7202, Case Postale 52, 61 rue Buffon, 75005 Paris, France
BMC Evolutionary Biology 2011, 11:316 doi:10.1186/1471-2148-11-316Published: 28 October 2011
Additional file 1:
Details for scleractinian specimens examined in the present study including GenBank accession data. Species name and GenBank accession numbers for sequences determined in the present study are underlined. Whenever possible, multiple samples of each species from different collection stations were sequenced and the resulting consensus sequences used in the analyses.
Format: DOC Size: 386KB Download file
This file can be viewed with: Microsoft Word Viewer
Additional file 2:
Anatomy of Gardineria, Letepsammia and other extant scleractinian corals. The figure compares Gardineria hawaiiensis (A-E), Letepsammia formosissima (F-J), Fungiacyathus margaretae (K-O), and Acropora millepora (P-U) at the levels of skeleton macromorphology (first column), anatomy (second column) and histology (columns 3-4) (S-U, courtesy of Dr. Tracy Ainsworth). Color arrows indicate the following anatomical and histological details: black arrows, mouth/pharynx position on cross-sectioned polyps; gray arrows, septal position; pink arrows, spermaries, white arrows, calicoblastic ectoderm; yellow arrows, mesoglea; green arrows, mesogleal plates; red arrow, muscle fibers; dark blue arrows, zooxanthellae; light blue arrows, cnidae; orange arrows, mucocytes. All cross sections are stained with Alcian Blue/PAS or haematoxylin and eosin. Cnidae are shown on sections of tentacle acrospheres (E, J, O, U). Fungiacyathus margaretae and Acropora millepora were used as typical representatives of deep-water (azooxanthellate) and tropical shallow-water (zooxanthellate) Scleractinia respectively. Although the three deep-water species have significantly thicker mesoglea and mesogleal plates, and more abundant mucocytes than does the shallow water coral (A. millepora), G. hawaiiensis and L. formosissima are typical scleractinians in terms of all histological features examined.
Format: JPEG Size: 8.9MB Download file
Additional file 3:
Initial ontogenetic stages in Gardineria hawaiiensis (A) and Letepsammia formosissima (B). The position of the six simultaneously inserted protosepta are indicated with white arrows. Thin section of the corallum base (A) and polished corallum base (B).
Format: JPEG Size: 6MB Download file
Additional file 4:
Skeletons of modern, deep-water representatives of the Basal clade of Scleractinia: Gardineriidae (Gardineria hawaiiensis) and Micrabaciidae (Letepsammia formosissima). While gardineriids have very robust coralla (A, B), micrabaciids typically have a light, lace-like skeleton with perforated walls and septa (B, D, E). Such lightly calcified skeletons are common in corals living close to or below the carbonate compensation depth (4500-5000 m; see also Additional file 6). In addition, uniquely amongst extant corals, the thickening deposits of micrabaciids are composed of a meshwork of short and extremely thin (ca. 100-300 nm) fibers with variable crystallographic orientation (G, I). In the case of gardineriids, distinctively from most deep-water scleractinians, which display aragonite fibers in large bundles (e.g., Desmophyllum) or in complex patterns (e.g., Flabellum), septal microstructure typically forms smaller, vesicular units (F, H, see also Additional file 6). The cyclical insertion pattern of septa in gardineriids (A) and micrabaciids (B) is typical of Scleractinia. However, both taxa show several unique features that distinguish them from other modern corals and from one another. In Gardineria (C) the outer part of the skeleton consists of a thick epithecal wall, which is unique to modern corals but was common among the earliest solitary anthozoans. In contrast, the synapticular wall of micrabaciids is highly porous (D). Unique features of modern micrabaciids are the multiple bifurcations of septa of the third order, straight and non-bifurcate septa of the first order (B), and thickening deposits (TD) composed of irregular meshwork of short fibers organized into small bundles (G, I). In contrast, a central line of well-organized rapid accretion centers and radiating bundles of fibers, formed by sequentially addition of micrometer-sized growth layers characterize Gardineria septal microstructure (F, H). Distal (A, B), proximal (D), and lateral (C, E) views are shown. Transverse polished and etched sections (F-I) of septa of G. hawaiiensis (F, H) and L. formosissima (G, I) with Rapid Accretion Deposits (RAD) surrounded by bundles of Thickening Deposits (TD). Scale bars 10 mm (A-E), and 20 μm (F-I).
Format: JPEG Size: 4.8MB Download file
Additional file 5:
Microstructural features of Letepsammia (Micrabaciidae), Gardineria (Gardineriidae) and other Recent scleractinian corals. The SEM micrographs shown are of etched polished surfaces of septa. In addition to differences in the distribution of Rapid Accretion Deposits (RAD), major differences can also be seen in the arrangement of the thickening deposits (TD). In Letepsammia formosissima (A), the TDs are composed of an irregular meshwork of fiber bundles oriented sub-parallel to the surface, whereas in Gardineria hawaiiensis (B), bundles of fibers (TD) form smaller, vesicular units. In Desmophyllum dianthus (C), Caryophyllia cyathus (D) and Favia stelligera (G), the TDs consist of bundles of fibers running perpendicular to the skeletal surface (in the case of the zooxanthellate coral Favia, these display high regularity, corresponding to daily growth increments). The TDs in Flabellum (E), Galaxea (F), and Acropora (H) show micro-laminar organization corresponding to the scale-like micro-texture of their skeleton surfaces.
Format: JPEG Size: 9MB Download file
Additional file 6:
Abyssal scleractinians. Of known scleractinians, representatives of Leptopenus (A, B) and Fungiacyathus (C, D) occur at the greatest depths (reaching depths > 5000), consequently developing fragile and thin skeletons of low density. The upper two images (A, B) are of a formaldehyde preserved specimen of Leptopenus, the bulk of the animal being composed of soft tissue (brown); the delicate skeleton (white) is deeply embedded within the polyp tissue. The two lower images (C, D) show the extremely thin, parchment-like skeleton of Fungiacyathus. Proximal views.
Format: JPEG Size: 6.9MB Download file