Table 2

Summary of potential unintended targets for primer pairs reported by QuantPrime and PRIMEGENESa
QuantPrime PRIMEGENS b
Total number of test cases 52 24
Number of cases where QuantPrime or PRIMEGENS was able to generate primers 38 15
Number of cases with potential unintended targets 12 14
Percentage of cases having at least one primer pair with potential unintended target 31.5% (12/38) 93.3% (14/15)
Number of total primer pairs generated 373 138
Number of primer pairs with potential unintended targets 50 60
Percentage of primer pairs with potential unintended targets 13.4% (50/373) 43.3% (60/138)
Number of potential unintended targets 162 116
Number of potential unintended targets with one or two mismatches to forward or reverse primer 30 4
Percentage of potential unintended targets with one or two mismatches to forward or reverse primer 18.5% (30/162) 3.4% (4/116)

a: Primer pairs generated by QuantPrime or PRIMEGENES from randomly selected templates (see Additional files 1 and 2 for details) were fed into Primer-BLAST for target specificity checking using the matching organism (i.e., Human for QuantPrime and Arabidopsis thaliana for PRIMEGENS) and matching database (RefSeq mRNA database for all cases). Default search parameters were used for Primer-BLAST searches which can detect targets with up to 5 mismatches to primers. Since QuantPrime and PRIMEGENES still use databases that are a few years old and Primer-BLAST uses the regularly updated NCBI database, we only counted those unintended targets found by Primer-BLAST that are also present in QuantPrime database (RefSeq 04/30/09 (reference assembly)(genome+) (splice variants)) or PRIMEGENS database (Arabidopsis TAIR9 cDNA) . The searches were performed between 2/3/2012 and 2/6/2012

b: Since PRIMEGENS adds non-specific primer pairs (i.e., pairs having more than one hybridization targets, see Additional file 2) to the primer result if it does not find sufficient number of target-specific primer pairs (i.e., pairs having only one hybridization target), we excluded all non-specific primer pairs in our analysis. In essence, our analysis only includes primer pairs that are deemed to be specific for the test template sequences by PRIMEGENS.

Ye et al.

Ye et al. BMC Bioinformatics 2012 13:134   doi:10.1186/1471-2105-13-134

Open Data